Disentangling Cartwright: Some remarks on the ontology of socioeconomic objects in the tangle of Science
The article seeks to specify and refine the concept of the “tangle of science” developed by Cartwright et al. (2022). This specification concerns tangles whose constitution involves typically socioeconomic objects, such as “inflation,” “unemployment rate,” and “poverty.” Unlike objects produced by science such as vaccines, medicines, or rockets, socioeconomic objects possess a specific ontology that ties their nature to particular spatial and temporal conditions in a way that differs fundamentally from objects like vaccines or pharmaceuticals. Second, we aim to refine the concept of the tangle of science as applied to socioeconomic objects by taking into account that the stability of these objects depends on collective intentionality—that is, on the human mind’s capacity to be directed (through beliefs, desires, preferences, and the like) toward objects and/or states of affairs external to itself. On the basis of this collective intentionality, human groups can create collective representations that categorize certain groups of individuals as “poor” or “unemployed,” as well as certain economic practices as “inflationary” or “deflationary.” The stability of these collective representations is sustained through power relations, whether in the form of violence, the attribution of rights and duties, or persuasion. At the same time, socioeconomic objects are also characterized by what the philosopher Ian Hacking has called looping effects. That is, when we classify someone as “poor,” “unemployed,” or “criminal,” such classifications may alter the behavior of the individuals so classified. As a consequence, theorizing about socioeconomic objects entails the risk of transforming the very collective representations and power relations that sustain them. In this respect, unlike a vaccine or a medicine—which may cure but do not generally alter a person’s identity—socioeconomic objects can be modified as they circulate within particular human groups. If the concept of the tangle of science is intended to track the reliability of scientific products (rather than to identify an ultimate method, rigor, or objectivity of scientific theories), then the reliability of socioeconomic objects can be understood as being closely tied to the contexts in which they are produced. This proximity, in turn, has important implications for the transportation of these objects across space and time. In other words, while a product such as a vaccine can be transported across different countries with only marginal changes in its reliability, the same does not necessarily hold for concepts such as “poverty” or “unemployment.” Accordingly, we argue that it is worthwhile to specify and refine the role of context, power relations, and looping effects in the constitution of socioeconomic objects—issues that are acknowledged in the 2022 book but not treated in a systematic way. Our work is exploratory in nature and aims to provide an ontology of the tangle for socioeconomic objects, understood as being sustained by power relations that vary across space and time. We propose to analyze power relations using Michel Foucault’s notion of the dispositif; the stabilization of particular material and discursive arrangements in specific contexts through Deleuze and Guattari’s concept of territorialization; and the processes of accommodation and resistance (following Andrew Pickering) that tangles composed of socioeconomic objects encounter when they are transported across different historical periods or spatial settings. As a practical illustration of the usefulness of these notions, we show how the concept of “poverty” traveled from the offices of the World Bank to Brazil from the late 1980s onward, being adapted and stabilized through a successful tangle that consolidated itself from the second half of the 2000s.
Area:
Keywords: Tangle of science; poverty; dispositif; territorialization; social ontology
Please Login in order to download this file