Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

From Scarcity to Sufficiency: Political Pressures, Institutional Power, and the Boundaries of Economic Thought

Kumar Nitesh, The New School
Sullivan Madeleine , The New School

This paper examines the political and institutional pressures that shaped the dominance of neoclassical economics in the twentieth century and the marginalization of alternative economic traditions. It argues that the consolidation of neoclassical theory was not solely the outcome of intellectual superiority, but was deeply intertwined with broader political, institutional, and methodological constraints that narrowed the scope of legitimate economic inquiry. The first section situates the rise of neoclassical economics within its historical and political context, tracing how the marginalist tools, rationality assumptions, and equilibrium frameworks gained dominance in academic institutions during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. It shows how these analytical choices aligned with dominant political pressures for value-free, policy‑neutral analysis, thereby strengthening their institutional legitimacy. The second section focuses on a key episode of dissent: the Oxford economists’ challenge to the Marshallian framework in the 1930s. Drawing on the contemporary studies based on the semi-structured interviews with the business leaders, it shows how core Marshallian concepts—such as marginal pricing and impact of interest rate on investment determination—were found to have limited relevance in actual business decision-making. The muted reception of these findings is interpreted as evidence of intellectual constraints within economics, where methodological conformity and institutional pressures discouraged sustained engagement with empirical anomalies. The final section explores how heterodox traditions—including Post-Keynesian, Degrowth, and Ecological Economics—have sought to respond to these constraints by redefining the aims and methods of economic analysis. It situates these approaches as attempts to resist the narrowing of economics under political and institutional pressure, particularly in the context of ecological limits and social well-being. The paper concludes by suggesting that revisiting neglected ethical and philosophical perspectives, including those of Gandhi and Tolstoy, can illuminate alternative conceptions of economic purpose that challenge the discipline’s entrenched assumptions.

Area:

Keywords: Anomalies, Paradigm Shift, Neoclassical Economics, Heterodox Economics