Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Is there a growth imperative in capitalist economies? A review of theories from Keynes and Schumpeter to modern approaches

Schmidt Johannes, Karlsruhe University of Applied Sciences

In his essay „The economic possibilities of our grandchildren“ Keynes reasoned about the possibility that a working week of 15 hours might be sufficient. However, five years before the date Keynes considered this possibility to be realistic we are still far away from realising it. One reason might be that the capitalist system has a kind of built-in growth imperative, i.e. it has to grow in order to be stable. The present paper reviews some older and more recent theories that try to prove that there is (or is not) such a growth imperative; the different theories are presented and compared. First, it is worked out more precisely what exactly the growth imperative is based on in the respective models; as a rule, it is very specific model assumptions that give rise to such a constraint. The next step is to examine the ‘assumption robustness’ of the models more closely, i.e. to ask how the model results change when the corresponding assumptions are relaxed. In many theories the monetary system is regarded to be a major reason for a growth imperative in capitalism. Therefore, the starting point are theories by Keynes and Schumpeter who emphasised the importance of monetary relations to analyse the capitalist system. Whereas Keynes and Schumpeter themselves did not seem to see a necessity for capitalism to grow permanently, more modern authors use theories of the monetary system inspired by Keynes and Schumpeter; they try to show that a growth imperative results mainly from the interplay of the investment behaviour of firms and the money creation of the banking system. They therefore propose changes in the monetary system that aim at preventing or restricting the banking system’s ability to create money. On the other hand, theories inspired – among other things – by Marxian theorising emphasize the necessity of firms to survive in market competition so that they are forced to introduce new technologies that lead to higher production. As this is regarded as a functional principle of capitalism it results in the necessity of the capitalist system to grow. All in all, it seems to be the case that the theories that the monetary system is responsible for a growth imperative is more questionable than the theories that emphasise technological progress and the constraints of markets.

Area:

Keywords: growth theory, growth imperative, monetary system, technological progress, market competition

Please Login in order to download this file