Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Economics and the antiquarian

d'onofrio federico, università di Bologna

The Italian writer Ferdinando Galiani argued that: "just like, having accumulated astronomical observations over many centuries, astronomers could easily figure out the laws of planetary motion, such is the case of the science of government.” The connection between early political economy and Newtonian science has been often remarked upon by historians of economics, but history, rather than the natural science, appeared to many the repository of observations needed to found the science of government, including in matters of trade and money. The Newtonianism of political economy relied indeed on the mobilization of historical material to estimate the magnitude of economic phenomena over time. In this sense, though, writers of trade and money were part of a broader phenomenon, a general change in the meaning of evidence, spearheaded by the renewal of historical methodology, and philology. The historian Arnaldo Momigliano stressed that the 18th century saw a revolution in historical writing, in response to the “historical pyrrhonism” of the late 17th century. Historians buttressed their theories with evidence provided by antiquarians and philologists, by the study of non-literary sources and material documents. Political economy partook of this general change alongside other disciplines – military studies, politics in general, art, linguistics, etc – but it was particularly well-suited to receive these changes because of its close connection with legal practices (many writers on trade and money taught in law schools), and 18th century legal practice centred around the investigation of precedents and the antiquity of rights and deeds. The importance of this kind of information for state building has been underlined among others by Jacob Soll study of Colbert’s mastering of archives. This contribution highlights how historical evidence was crucial to the emergence of a science of political economy in Europe during the “economic turn” of the mid-18th century. By looking at works from France (Dutot), Scotland (Hume), and Naples (Galiani and GenovesI), it focuses in particular on two debates: the discussion on population as an indicator of national wealth and the debate on prices and monetary policy. It shows that writers on trade and money investigated ancient historical texts with new eyes, went to archives, and also analyzed coin collections and epigraphs to collect evidence and construct historical time series.

Area:

Keywords: 18th century, evidence, methodology, historiogray, epistemology

Please Login in order to download this file