Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Economists on demand: evidence-based policymaking and credibility in recent context

Edwards José, Independent Scholar

This project examines the effects of social intrusions in economics with focus on the credibility revolution in econometrics. Identified long ago by historians of economics (e.g., Coats 1969, Goodwin 1998), such intrusions often result from demands on economists coming from diverse players (e.g., government officers, congress staff, bankers, independent research organizations, business firms, etc.). Confronted with different actions those demands have in several cases shaped up economics outside-in to the point of affecting its academic foundations. Documented by historians of statistics (Desrosieres 1998, Porter 2006) and incorporated to the history macroeconomics (e.g., Renault 2023, Backhouse & Cherrier 2023), interactions between public governance and economics has been also studied through the demobilization of economists and subsequent postwar efforts to develop both social engineering programs and market regulations (e.g., O’Connor 2001, Berman 2022, Dupont-Kieffer et al. 2024). The present inquiry extends that approach and examines the so-called “applied turn” in economics (Backhouse & Cherrier 2017, Panhans & Singleton 2017) as the result of intrusions coming from new public management (Davies et al. 2000). Focused on transparency, accountability, and demands for credible evaluations of policymaking and government, this new agenda has affected not only the evaluative practices of economists but also the academic base of the discipline (Netto 2021). References Berman. E. P. (2022). Thinking like an economist. Princeton University Press: Princeton. Backhouse, R. & B. Cherrier (2017). “The Age of the Applied Economist: The Transformation of Economics since the 1970s.” History of Political Economy. 49(S1): 1–33. Backhouse, R. & B. Cherrier (2023). “Towards a broader history of modern macroeconomics.” European Economic Review. 159: 1-6. Coats, A.W. (1969). “Research priorities in the history of economics.” History of Political Economy. 1(1): 9-18. Davies, H., S. Nutley. P. Smith. (Eds.) (2000). What Works? Evidence-based policy and practice in public services. The Policy Press: Bristol. Desrosières, A. (1998). The Politics of Large Numbers. Harvard University Press: Cambridge. Dupont-Kieffer, A., R. Dimand, S. Rivot. (2024). “Introduction to Economists at War: How World War II Changed Economics (and Vice Versa).” History of Political Economy. 56 (S1): 1-27. Goodwin, C. (1998). “The Patrons of Economics in a Time of Transformation.” History of Political Economy. 30(S1): 53-81. Netto, A. (2021). “Experiments in the armchair: a history of microeconometrics and program evaluation at Princeton.” PhD thesis, 277p. O’Connor, A. (2001). Poverty Knowledge: Social Science, Social Policy, and the Poor in Twentieth-Century U.S. History. Princeton University Press: Princeton. Panhans, M. & Singleton, J. (2017). “The Empirical Economist's Toolkit: From Models to Methods.” History of Political Economy. 49(Supplement): 127-157. Porter, T. M. (2006). “Speaking Precision to Power: The Modern Political Role of Social Science.” Social Research. 73(4): 1273-1294. Renault, M. (2023). “Macroeconomics under Pressure: The Feedback Effects of Economic Expertise.” The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought. 30(2): 275-298.

Area:

Keywords: History of recent economics, credibility revolution, historiography