Ideas in Exile
This paper argues that censorship and self-censorship, rather than exile alone, constituted the primary mechanisms through which political pressure reshaped the international circulation, legitimacy, and content of economic ideas in the mid-twentieth century. Focusing on the University in Exile at the New School for Social Research (founded in 1933), the paper demonstrates how economists displaced by authoritarian regimes navigated new political and institutional constraints that redefined what counted as acceptable economic knowledge. Alvin Johnson founded the University in Exile in response to the suppression of academic freedom in Europe, yet the institution offered conditional intellectual freedom rather than an unqualified refuge. While émigré economists escaped direct state censorship, they confronted new forms of pressure arising from American academic norms, philanthropic oversight, and an evolving political climate (Friedlander, 2019; Mongiovi, 2005). These pressures shaped not only institutional arrangements but also economists’ theoretical vocabularies, methodological commitments, and normative claims. Exile thus operated as a site where political limits continued to structure economic discourse rather than disappearing. The paper distinguishes two waves of émigré economists whose responses to these constraints differed systematically. The first wave (1933–1934), largely composed of German-speaking scholars from the Weimar Republic, including Emil Lederer, Eduard Heimann, Frieda Wunderlich, Karl Brandt, Gerhard Colm, and Hans Staudinger, introduced traditions of political economy grounded in social ethics, institutional analysis, and normative critique (Hagemann, 2005). The second wave (1940–1942), including Adolf Lowe, Hans Neisser, Jacob Marschak, Abba Lerner, and Franco Modigliani, reformulated these traditions in an environment increasingly oriented toward formalization, empirical methods, and policy relevance. Drawing on archival and interpretive sources, the paper shows how exile generated distinctive forms of self-censorship that structured theoretical innovation. Émigré economists reframed ethical commitments as methodological instruments, translated normative arguments into analytic frameworks, and recoded critical political economy to align with American expectations of scientific neutrality. Through close examination of Lowe’s instrumental methodology, Heimann’s ethical conception of the social economy, Marschak’s synthesis of formal and empirical methods, and Modigliani’s doctoral thesis written at the New School, the paper demonstrates how political pressure fostered intellectual recombination rather than mere accommodation. By analysing the University in Exile as a mediating institution rather than a passive conduit, the paper contributes to the history of economic thought by showing how economists under pressure negotiated the political limits of their discipline. It reveals how censorship and self-censorship reshaped the transnational circulation of economic ideas and produced hybrid forms of economics that bridged European humanism and American institutionalism, leaving a durable imprint on modern economics (Hagemann, 2017). Selected References Friedlander, J. (2019). A light in Dark Times: The New School for Social Research and the University in Exile, Columbia. Hagemann, H. (2005). Dismissal, Expulsion, and Emigration of German-Speaking Economists after 1933, JHET, 27:4. Hagemann, H. (2017). Franco Modigliani as "American" Keynesian: How the University in Exile Economists Influenced Economics, Social Research: 84:4. Mongiovi, G. (2005). Emigré Economists and American Neoclassical Economics, 1933–1945, JHET 27(4).
Area:
Keywords: Economists under pressure; Censorship and self-censorship; Intellectual exile; University in Exile (New School for Social Research); Transnational circulation of economic ideas; History of economic thought
Please Login in order to download this file