Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Thorstein B. Veblen as an Early Reminder of Diversity in Economics and American Institutionalism: Conspicuous Consumption and its Relevance in Social Sciences

Dieter Bögenhold, Klagenfurt University

The paper has two aims: Firstly, Veblen is the most representative author of early American institutionalism and will be portrayed and discussed in the historical context of his writing and emergence. Second, Veblen’s most famous concept of conspicuous consumption will be discussed in terms of its principles and contemporary relevance. It can be said that, from today's perspective, Veblen and his concept of conspicuous consumption are a pivotal example of interdisciplinary social science. Thorstein B. Veblen is part of a historical irony: the famous John Bates Clark was one of the founders of American neoclassical economics, and one of the most prestigious prizes that US economists can receive from the AEA is still the John Bates Clark Medal. John Bates Clark’s son, John Maurice Clark, studied under Veblen and absorbed many institutionalist ideas, even though his father was one of Veblen’s chief targets. These circumstances set up a fascinating generational tension: Veblen attacked the father’s theory but influenced the son’s thinking. Veblen must be regarded as a pioneer of evolutionary and institutional economics. Consumption patterns demonstrate the social position of their users. Purchasing wealthy objects can give satisfaction, “joy”, and “pleasure” to the buyer. Purchases often also highlight the owners' economic and social position. The availability of expensive, rare goods can indicate the social power of their owners. Thorstein B. Veblen was the first author to examine the social logic of purchasing and owning goods in his book, “Theory of the Leisure Class” (1899), using these practices to highlight power and demonstrate social distinction. The article will revisit Veblen and examine the recent relevance of the conspicuous consumption perspective, as well as its specific terminology. In most contemporary societies, the creation and maintenance of differences drive social change and its dynamics. Luxury consumption as a field of research encompasses a range of perspectives. First, does owning luxury goods make its owners happier? Second, is the desire for distinction a force that keeps societies going when people compete for scarce goods and services as recognition or achievement? Is the ambition for creating differences as a so-called rationality of irrationality manifested in specific consumption patterns a principal feature of modern capitalist societies? Third, can luxury consumption be considered unethical in cases where people spend a lot of money to buy items for prestigious distinction, while other people struggle for elementary forms of life simultaneously? Although Veblen is regarded as one of the fathers of contemporary economics, he has also achieved the status of a classic in sociological studies. In many respects, DiMaggio’s statement that the “starting point of any discussion of lifestyles and consumption patterns must be the work of Thorstein Veblen and Pierre Bourdieu” (DiMaggio, 1994, p. 458) applies to the fundamentals of consumption practices. It is interesting enough that even at Veblen's time a lively discussion between European and North American scientists took place. Veblen had already quoted Max Weber’s The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, and he had letter exchanges with Schmoller and other major contemporaries. The paper will refer to Veblen as an early reminder of diversity in economics and as a contemporary interdisciplinary classic in the social sciences.

Area:

Keywords: Eerly American Institutionalism, History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches