Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Copper Money and Monetary Thought in the 17th Century Northern Europe: The Big Problem of Small Change Revisited

Raskov Danila, Uppsala University
Ögren Anders, Uppsala University

Carlo Cipolla coined a standard formula for the big problem of small change: regulating the quantity of money (against counterfeiting), allowing the face value of coins to exceed their intrinsic value (fiat component), and ensuring convertibility of small denominations into units of account (1956). François Velde and Thomas Sargent’s The Big Problem of Small Change developed this formula, arguing that debasement helped maintain the elasticity of supply. They constructed a model and used it to select a biased sample that fit their framework (2002, 37). The historical process of five hundred years (1300-1850) was presented as if it were a slow cumulative progress of both monetary practices and ideas. In our paper, we are challenging this view and dealing carefully with the monetary practices and thought of Sweden during the copper standard (1624-1776). Monetary theories have become part of the discussion of monetary problems. Nevertheless, methodologically, we proceed from the assumption that the economic facts of the seventeenth century are too rich to be reduced to a single model. Additionally, treating stability as the goal of the monetary system is an oversimplification, since it was subject to external shocks from wars and other political threats. The article shows that linear progress was not characteristic of either ideas or practices. Rather, development followed a cyclical pattern. In 1624, a copper standard was introduced in Sweden. It remained in place until 1776. In addition to Stockholm, this decision affected monetary circulation in major Baltic trading cities of the seventeenth century. Copper money, denominated both in copper dalers and silver dalers, coexisted with gold coins and silver coins, measured in riksdaler, courant, or carolin. The resulting monetary system, with parallel standards and multiple currencies, was complex. On the basis of empirical evidence, this article demonstrates that the authorities controlled the money supply, manipulated devaluation, and made partial use of convertibility. From HET’s perspective, the article shows that monetary theory and policy before Adam Smith reveal not a linear progress, but rather a collection of practical insights and competing doctrines (Monroe 1923). Many authors (Axel Oxenstierna, Emanuel Swedenborg, and Anders Nordencrantz) recognized the necessity of limiting the supply of fractional money, the possibility of enlarging the fiat component, and enforcing convertibility. Oxenstierna, A. (1630) Betänkande om kopparhandeln och kopparmyntningen », (1630), in : Rikskansleren Axel Oxenstiernas skrifter och brefvexling, vol. I, no 1, Historiska och politiska skrifter, Stockholm, K. Kungl. Vitterhetsakademien, 1888. Swedenborg, E. (1722) Oförgriplige tankar om myntets upphöjande och nedsättande, Uppsala, Edman, 1771. Cipolla C.M. (1956) Money, Prices and Civilization in the Mediterranean World: Fifth to Seventeenth Century. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Monroe A. (1930) Monetary theory before Adam Smith. Ögren A. & L. Runefet (2014) Argent, cuivre, papier: l’évolution des idées monétaires en Suède,1521-1776. In: Les pensées monétaires dans l’histoire. L’Europe, 1517–1776. Blanc J, Desmedt L (eds). Paris: Classiques Garnier, 899–940. Sargent T. J. & F. R. Velde (2002). The Big Problem of Small Change. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press. Wolontis J. (1936) Kopparmyntingen i Sverige 1624–1714. Helsingfors. (Coauthor is Anders Ögren, professor of Uppsala University)

Area:

Keywords: Swedish economic thought, Monetary theory, Copper, Commodity, Oxenstierna, Swedenborg, 17th century

Please Login in order to download this file