Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

THIN NUMBERS, THICK DEPRIVATIONS: HISTORY AND METHODOLOGY OF POVERTY MEASUREMENT

Judith Favereau, Université Lumière Lyon 2

Poverty has an abundance and diversity of statistical measures. Yet, despite this diversity, when poverty is measured several paradoxes emerge, leading to refinements of its measurement. Sketching the history of poverty measurement can be seen as drawing the history and resolution of these paradoxes. Nonetheless, one paradox appears persistent for most of the poverty measures: the so-called mortality paradox. The more poverty kills, the fewer poor people there are, and the lower the poverty measure is. Lefebvre, Pestieau, and Ponthière (2013) and Mukherjee (2007) speak of the “missing poor” or the “mortality paradox.” Rare reflections on the definition (shaping) of poverty as deprivation have not yet been conducted in connection with the mortality paradox, or with mortality more generally. Nevertheless, Sen (1993, 1998) paves the way by questioning the value of using a mortality indicator to measure economic success or failure. According to Sen (1993, 1998), mortality data reveal the deprivations faced by individuals. This raises a central methodological question about measurement in general: what do numbers reveal or hide? This methodological tension typically results in a distinction between 'thin' and 'thick' measurement. The latter emphasises that measurement is often value-laden, particularly in the social sciences, and calls for democratic and pluralistic measurement indicators (Alessandrova & Fabian, 2022; Thoma, 2023). The aim of this paper is to highlight the importance of mortality as a dimension of poverty measurement, in order to address these two epistemological issues and propose an alternative methodology. Following the approach pioneered by Sen (1998) and focusing on mortality data to measure poverty may help address these issues (i.e. concealment and values). Firstly, mortality data encapsulates various deprivations. Consequently, it could indicate areas of focus and how to address them without being unduly burdensome. Secondly, mortality data could reveal values hidden behind common poverty measures. Therefore, mortality data appears to be a valuable tool for reinforcing public deliberation on the measurement of social indicators, such as those relating to poverty. The paper proceeds as follows. The first section outlines the history of poverty measurement in economics, highlighting the 'mortality paradox'. The second section articulates the two epistemological tensions within measurement that are exemplified by the 'mortality paradox'. The third section opens up the paradox. It does this by calling on mobilizing mortality data. This is a way to deal with the tension between reveal and conceal in measurement. It is also a way to tackle explicitly the values behind poverty measurement. The fourth section illustrates an alternative methodology of poverty measurement by focusing on participatory measures to produce democratic and pluralistic indicators. The final section concludes. References Alessandrova, A., & Fabian, M. (2022). Democratising measurement: or Why Thick Concepts Call for Coproduction. European Journal for Philosophy of Science, 12(7), 6-29. Fleurbaey, M., & Ponthiere, G. (2022). Measuring well-being and lives worth living. Economic Theory, 1-20. Fleurbaey, M., Leroux, M. L., & Ponthiere, G. (2014). Compensating the dead. Journal of Mathematical Economics, 51, 28-41. Kanbur, R., & Mukherjee, D. (2007). Premature mortality and poverty measurement. Bulletin of economic Research, 59(4), 339-359. Lefebvre, M., Pestieau, P., & Ponthière, G. (2013). Measuring poverty without the mortality paradox. Social Choice and Welfare, 40, 285-316. Sen, A. (1998). Mortality as an indicator of economic success and failure. The economic journal, 108(446), 1-25. Sen, A. (1993). The economics of life and death. Scientific American, 268(5), 40-47. Thoma, J. (2024). Social Sciences, Policy and Democracy. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 52(1), 5-41.

Area:

Keywords: poverty, measurement, history, methodology, public deliberation

Please Login in order to download this file