Auguste and Léon Walras' conception of social justice through land nationalisation policy
(Session en français) This article offers a rereading of Walrasian social justice theory through the lens of land nationalization policy, closely articulating the thoughts of Auguste and Léon Walras. The defended hypothesis holds that Léon Walras's exact conception of justice —often reduced to a mere moral corrective to general equilibrium theory— can only be understood by repositioning it within the normative horizon inherited from his father, where land ownership emerges as the nodal point of conflict over merit. The doctrinal lineage between father and son reveals that Walrasian justice is neither a late addition to market mechanics nor a rhetorical concession, but a genuine project to refound the social order based on a natural right to the soil and a republican demand for equality of conditions. First, the article analyzes Auguste Walras's philosophy of wealth, which rigorously distinguishes natural wealth (land) from productive wealth (fruits of individual labor), and views private land ownership as a historical usurpation generating unjustified rent and hereditary inequalities. The proposal for progressive nationalization of land, via state repurchase, appears as an "agrarian law" aimed at restoring natural right and funding solidarity without resorting to taxation, in the name of a social truth where only labor deserves reward. Second, the article shows how Léon Walras takes up and transforms this heritage in his writings on social economy, formulating a meritocratic theory of justice: the state as landowner captures the land value increment arising from collective progress, ensuring both equality of conditions (distributive justice) and recognition of differences in talents and efforts (commutative justice). Land nationalization policy is no longer merely a technical program but the pivot of a conception of justice that articulates individual liberty, competitive markets, and the fight against unmerited rent. This reconstruction, at the interface of economic thought history and political philosophy, sheds new light on contemporary debates on land rent taxation, meritocracy theories, and social justice models in market economies, highlighting the Walras duo's relevance for renewed dialogue between philosophy and economics.
Area:
Keywords: Walras; land nationalization; social justice; land rent; equality
Please Login in order to download this file