Le rôle du temps dans les Éléments d’économie politique pure de Walras
The understanding of the role played by time in Léon Walras’s pure economics has relevant consequences for two of the fundamental controversies in the interpretation of the Elements, namely those about the meaning of tâtonnement and the mechanism of capital formation. Interpreting the object of pure economics either as an atemporal structure or as concretely evolving process entails opposite positions in both debates. About the first issue, an atemporal interpretation of general equilibrium has been advanced since Jaffé. In this view, equilibrium is assumed not to be concerned with the description of empirical market transactions, but rather to be oriented to the analysis of the properties of an ideal system that ensure justice in exchange. From this perspective, tâtonnement is seen as a purely logical procedure, guaranteeing that an iterative solution to the equations of GE can be achieved via price movements. This interpretation contrasts with the reading of general equilibrium, recently defended by Walker, as a representation of concrete market phenomena. Here tâtonnement becomes the description of the real process, taking place in time, of convergence towards equilibrium via a series of out-of-equilibrium transactions. No less controversial are the consequences of adopting either a static or a dynamic framework for capitalization. In the former case (as in Garegnani), the equilibrium sets out the stationary conditions for the reproduction of a given economic system. By contrast, in a dynamic interpretation (as in Donzelli) capital accumulation will be read as the succession of instantaneous equilibria, each of them characterized by a different stock of capital goods and, hence, by a different rate of net income on newly produced capital goods. In my paper, I aim to provide a systematic analysis of Walras’s references to the notion of time in the Elements. I argue that more light can be shed on these controversies by emphasizing that, according to Walras, pure economics deals with two distinct types of laws, i.e. the laws of price determination and those of price variation. The former require a complete abstraction from time. The latter however require the reinjection of time, not to study the out-of-equilibrium equilibrating process, but rather to compare different equilibrium positions and to provide an outline of the causes and consequences of economic progress. The incorporation of time is then done not to ensure realisticness, but rather to isolate the general conditions of possibility for an increase in per capita wealth, even in a context of land scarcity. An algorithmic interpretation of tâtonnement should therefore not necessarily lead to either interpreting equilibrium as stationary or viewing Walras’s theory of capital accumulation as a foreign body to pure economics.
Area:
Keywords: Léon Walras, General Equilibrium, Capital Accumulation, Logical vs Historical Time
Please Login in order to download this file