Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

U.S. Fiscal Advisors and Tax Reform under Authoritarian Rule: Richard A. Musgrave and C. Lowell Harriss in Taiwan

Cheng Chung-Tang, National Taipei University

This article examines how two American economists influenced postwar Taiwan’s tax reforms. In 1968, Richard A. Musgrave (1910–2007) visited Taiwan and produced “The Musgrave Report,” which became a key basis for the 1969 revision of the Income Tax Act. On the other hand, C. Lowell Harriss (1912–2009) came to Taiwan in 1971 and submitted “The Harriss Report,” advocating land tax reform in line with the People’s Livelihood principle of Sun Yat-sen’s Three People’s Principles. However, his proposal was disregarded, and land tax reform was not implemented until after the 1977 amendment to the Equalization of Land Rights Act. By reviewing the historical contexts of these two reform efforts, this article seeks to explain why the Kuomintang authoritarian government responded differently to the two proposals. The Musgrave Report was swiftly accepted reflects both Ta-Chung Liu’s authority as Chiang Kai-shek's chief economic adviser and the policy urgency surrounding income tax reform. However, even Liu – and later Harriss – faced constraints in the realm of land tax reform, where he was checked by local land economists. The dispute also hinged on how to interpret Sun Yat-sen’s teachings and translate them into a reform program that could credibly claim fidelity to that legacy.

Area:

Keywords: tax reform, Musgrave, Harriss, Taiwan, Ta-Chung Liu

Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.