Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

A “sterile” concept of “population optimum” in economics?

RANCAN ANTONELLA, University of Molise

Among the influential contributions to economics of 2024 Nobel laureate Daron Acemoglu (with Simon Johnson and James A. Robinson) are his joint works with Pascual Restrepo on the consequences of population ageing for economic growth (2017; 2021). According to them, ageing represents a stimulus to innovation, particularly through automation: when the supply of young workers declines, especially in sectors intensive in manual labor, firms respond by investing in robots and new technologies. Their conclusion is not new in the history of economic thought. On the contrary, the relationship between population dynamics and economic growth has long been a central and contested issue among economists. One may go back to Malthus, to Keynes’s ambivalent position on population (1919, ch. 2; 1937; see also Petersen 1955; Simon 2018), and to the stagnation and underpopulation theories of the 1940s, beginning with Hansen (1939), up to more recent debates on secular stagnation (e.g. Gordon 2016). This paper explores economists’ approaches to the concept of optimum population, according to Myrdal (1940) “one of the most sterile ideas ever developed in economics,” yet one of the most pervasive notions in theorizing about economic development and welfare maximization, as well as in policymakers’ concerns. Given the strong policy implications embedded in the idea of an optimal population, the paper also investigates how shifts in economic thinking about population have interacted with changing policy contexts. In particular, while population analysis was prominent among economists during the authoritarian regimes of the 1920s and 1930s—owing to the close link between population doctrines and policy—demographic theorizing lost prominence after World War II, as economists grew increasingly suspicious of normative claims about an “optimum” population. Interest in population issues partially re-emerged with the rise of development economics (see Fogel’s Nobel Lecture, 1993 [1997]) and again in the 1970s within life-cycle approaches to growth (Brumberg and Modigliani 1954; Ando and Modigliani 1963). References Acemoglu, D., e Restrepo, P. (2017). Secular stagnation? The effect of aging on economic growth in the age of automation. American Economic Review, 107(5), 174-179. Acemoglu, D., e Restrepo, P. (2021). Demographics and automation. The Review of Economic Studies, 89(1), 1-44. Ando A. K., e Modigliani, F. (1963). The ‘Life Cycle’ Hypothesis of Savings: Aggregate Implications and Tests. American Economic Review, 33(1), 55–84. Brumberg, R. and Modigliani, F. (1954). Utility Analysis and the Consumption Function: An Interpretation of Cross-Sectional Data. In Post Keynesian Economics, Ed. K. K. Kurhiara. Fogel, R. W. (1997). Economic growth, population theory. In Economic Sciences, 1991-1995, 3, 72. Gordon, R. (2016). The Rise and Fall of American Growth. The US standard of living since the civil war. Princeton University Press. Hansen, A. H. (1939). Economic Progress and Declining Population Growth. American Economic Review, 29(1), 1–15. Keynes, J. M. 1919. The Economic Consequences of the Peace, London. Keynes, J. M. (1937) [1978]. Some economic consequences of a declining population. Myrdal, G. (1940). Population: A Problem for Democracy. Harvard University Press. Petersen, W. (1955). John Maynard Keynes's theories of population and the concept of “optimum”. Population Studies, 8(3), 228-246. Simon, J. (2018). The Economics of Population: Key Classic Writings. Routledge.

Area:

Keywords: population optimum, economic growth, stagnation

Please Login in order to download this file