Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Bentham and the Colonisation of Australia (1831) as a Solution to Indigence: A re-examination from an Economic Perspective

Sigot Nathalie, TRIANGLE, Univ. Lyon 2 / PHARE, Univ. Paris 1

Bentham’s last writing on the colonies, entitled "Colonization Company Proposal", has long been interpreted as a shift in his position regarding colonisation: whereas he had previously issued numerous calls for the emancipation of the colonies, by 1831 he was defending the establishment of a settlement colony in Australia. His conversion to colonialism is hypothesised to have been caused by either his legislative ambition, the awareness of the dangers of capitalism, or by the influence exerted by Wakefield, who claimed to have convinced him of the benefits of colonisation. But literature scarcely mentions, except in passing, a key element in Bentham’s project that makes it stand out from his earlier writings on the colonies: the aim was to send poor people to Australia in order to reduce the taxes levied for poor relief, the steady and rapid increase of which had become a source of concern. The link between colonisation and poverty was certainly not original at the time; but the literature on Bentham has focused primarily on whether he changed his mind about colonisation and, if so, the reasons for this change, without entering into a detailed study of the proposals he made in 1831 in relation to his concerns about poverty management. The aim of this paper is to highlight this aspect and to show that, from a strictly economic point of view, the project of establishing a colony in Australia is comparable to the one Bentham had previously imagined to solve the problem of poverty in England (the industry houses): part I of the paper shows that Bentham’s proposal to dispatch impoverished individuals to the colony, who were deemed to be at risk of becoming indigent and reliant on poor relief in England, served as a response to one of the fundamental criticisms he himself had previously levelled at the practice of colonisation. As a result, Bentham did not subscribe to Wakefield’s central principle of ‘sufficient price’ for land: the possibility for the poor of becoming owners of the supposedly vacant land in Australia, which was Wakefield’s reason for the colonies’ inability to progress for it would create a labour shortage, served in Bentham as an incentive mechanism for work, replacing those he had discussed in his writings on the poor (part II).

Area:

Keywords: Bentham ; Colonisation ; "sufficient price" ; poverty ; Australia

Please Login in order to download this file