Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Another End of History: Difficulties in the Path of a Deconstructive Economic Methodology

De Michele Giustino, Aix-Marseille Université

From the early 1990s to the early 2000s, spurred by the 1980s linguistic turn, the project of a postmodern economic epistemology emerged within an American heterodox Marxist milieu. In this context, Derridian deconstruction itself was advanced (Ruccio, Amariglio, Rossetti) as a perspective within economic methodology, more insightful than other pragmatist or postmodern options. However, this graft proved short-lived. While rhetorical analysis exposes hidden contradictions and situated stances within scientific discourse, deconstruction treats contradictions not as problems to be resolved but as markers of an irreducibly aporetic structure of reality. This fundamental stance made deconstruction difficult to integrate into economic methodology, prompting McCloskey’s preference for “American or British” approaches to discursive criticism or Davis’s observation that deconstruction’s “radical and substantial” philosophical assumptions lacked elaboration in this context. This paper argues that the failure of deconstructive economics was not merely theoretical, but also historical. Derrida’s engagement with political economy in Specters of Marx (1993) advocated a return to Marx at a moment when the neoliberal paradigm seemed uncontested following the USSR’s collapse, explicitly countering Fukuyama’s The End of History? (1989). Similarly, early-1990s calls for deconstructive economics coincided with a period when dominant methodologies could be challenged discursively rather than revolutionary, yet this critical intellectual freedom was grounded in the absence of viable alternatives, hence fleeting. Emerging from a political-institutional conjuncture that seemingly neutralized the political dimension of economic thought, deconstructive economics promised a radical critique of neoliberal hegemony and methodological orthodoxy as supposedly neutral discursive regimes (see Mirowski 2013). By the early 2000s, deconstruction had begun its decline in the humanities, and deconstructive economic methodology effectively ceased (Ruccio & Amariglio, 2003). A new “return to order” made such speculative approaches untenable, as a logic of emergency reduced the legitimacy of non-instrumental critical approaches. Today, deconstructive economics can be remembered as an aborted attempt. In reactionary public educational discourse – in France as in the United States – deconstruction has become the epitome of intellectual evil, and deconstructive thought portrayed as a gangrene threatening universities and social bodies. Yet, a new turn in economic history, inseparable from an authoritarian and anti-academic turn in American history, challenges this verdict. The neoliberal order of the 1990s may now be fatally destabilized, as economic relations once again seem to continue war by other means. In this context, counterintuitively, a renewed attempt at deconstructive economic philosophy, questioning the boundaries of the economic, the theoretical, and the political (Berns 2012), regains pertinence.

Area:

Keywords: Postmodern economics, Deconstruction, “End of History” thesis, Neoliberal hegemony

Please Login in order to download this file