Smith on Consent and Compulsion in Labor Markets: Examining the Influence of Scholastic Thought
Recent research analyzing Adam Smith’s moral evaluation of the market has emphasized its dual nature. While recognizing the weight Smith places on the trust, probity and punctuality that is fostered by a commercial republic, scholarship has also observed the significant instances he raises of socially harmful consequences associated with market-based exchange. In particular Smith’s analysis of monopolistic privileges and price-fixing conspiracies have been given prominence. Research on the influences on Smith’s treatment of these cases has largely focused on the role of the Protestant natural law tradition in shaping his perspective on economic justice in the product market. The manner in which key concepts underlying voluntary and involuntary exchange in earlier Scholastic thinking underlie his approach to labor markets remains largely unexplored. This study affirms that a fuller understanding of Smith’s economic and moral evaluation of markets is obtained through analyzing his treatment of consent and compulsion (both physical and economic) in labor markets and examining the influences of Scholastic thinking upon it. In discussing employment opportunities and wage negotiations, Smith affirms voluntary exchange should prevail. Smith stresses the “sacred and inviolable” right of the worker to provide his labor and condemns legal limitations on a laborer’s employment as “a manifest encroachment upon [their] just liberty.” In addition to challenging apprenticeship laws and regulations inhibiting the movement of laborers, Smith highlights the element of compulsion facing workers. In critiquing economic malfeasance in labor markets, Smith draws on conceptions of consent and compulsion found in both High Scholastic and Late (Spanish) Scholastic thought. Exponents of the Scholastic tradition wrestled with the conditions under which laborers participated consensually for payment in comparison to instances of economic duress in taking employment and compensation. The influence of this distinction is evident in Smith’s inquiry. In his presentation of Europe’s economic development, Smith stresses the use of brute force in buttressing the dependence of servile relationships which characterized feudal economies. While he accords superiority to the commercial republic which displaced the feudal order, Smith nonetheless observes economic compulsion can characterize labor market activity. Examples explored in this paper include Smith’s analysis of laws governing labor market combinations in England generating economic disadvantages to laborers, slavery as practiced in the British Empire, and the monopsonistic wages paid by joint-stock companies in South Asia. Concluding remarks are presented on the continuities and discontinuities found in Smith’s analysis with Scholastic conceptions and applications of consent and compulsion.
Area:
Keywords: SMITH CONSENT ECONOMIC COMPULSION SCHOLASTIC THOUGHT
Please Login in order to download this file