Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Between Sovereignty and Science: The “Guanzi” Tradition and the Political Limits of Chinese Monetary Thought (1927–1949)

ZHANG Gabriel Shouyi, LEFMI - UPJV

This paper examines how political pressures and deeply rooted institutional traditions defined the "limits of the possible" for economic science in modern China. It argues that the Guanzi tradition—a pre-modern intellectual lineage that conceptualizes money as a strategic instrument of the sovereign to manage social order—provided a persistent ideological substrate that constrained the professionalization and autonomy of monetary thought during the turbulent mid-20th century. This research focuses on the period of 1927–1949. As China navigated the existential crises of the end of Warlord era, the Anti-Japanese War, and the subsequent Civil War, domestic economists found their intellectual space increasingly curtailed by the state's wartime mobilization. The study analyzes the tension between the modern economic training of these scholars—many educated in Western traditions of market-based monetary stability—and the "strong institutional pressures" to endorse state-led inflationary finance and centralized currency control. Through an analysis of academic journals, policy memoranda, and the monetary reforms by National Government (Tael Altered into Yuan, Fabi Reform, and 1948 Golden Yuan Reform), the paper illustrates how political power curated economic knowledge. In times of hyperinflationary crisis, the state frequently regressed to a "command-and-control" logic reminiscent of the ancient Qingzhong (Light-Heavy) philosophy, effectively silencing voices that advocated for independent monetary constraints. By tracing these "political limits," the study highlights the strategies of adaptation and self-censorship employed by Chinese economists as they navigated a highly restrictive institutional context. Ultimately, this research demonstrates how a dominant political narrative can stifle theoretical plurality and force the regression of economic science into a tool of authoritarian governance, offering a non-Western perspective on the political boundaries of economic thought.

Area:

Keywords: History of Chinese Economic Thought, Political Limits to Economics, Monetary Sovereignty, Guanzi (Qingzhong) Tradition, Economists under Pressure

Please Login in order to download this file