[YSP] Endogenous Money Theories, Treasury Economists and the Treasury Circuit in Interwar and Postwar France
As of today, money is almost unanimously viewed as endogenous: monetary aggregates cannot be set by any authority but rather are determined by the demand for money balances from non-banks at a set short-term interest rate. They are the result of influxes of credit money and asset sales to banks, and of refluxes through credit repayment and asset purchases from banks. Endogenous money, in its contemporary version, is often described as a Post-Keynesian finding dating back to the 1970s, fostered by Anglo-Saxon economists Kaldor, Moore, Chick, Davidson. Yet, contributions by French economist Jacques Le Bourva as early as 1959 and 1962 already exposed the main foundations of endogenous money theory and were spotted by Lavoie (1992). Our work addresses the following question: which intellectual and institutional context made the emergence of such a pioneering endogenous money view possible in postwar France? We trace back Le Bourva’s acknowledged influences to answer this question. First, we describe how a group of authors that Le Bourva called “practitioners” (ie non-academic economists) were in the vanguard of explaining monetary phenomena in the 1950s by demand-side factors: Gilbert Devaux, François Bloch-Lainé and Pierre de Vogüé were civil servants at the French Treasury and their works tried to understand the determinants of the Treasury situation. Doing so, they came to the conclusion that the Treasury liquid reserves were not dependent on the execution of the budget but rather on general monetary cycles. This was because the Treasury at the time endorsed the role of a large deposit bank, the “Treasury circuit”: the flows it received were endogenous, allowing economists to understand money as endogenous. Second, economists from the Banque de France Pierre Berger and from the Crédit Lyonnais Jean Denizet focused more on the effect of Treasury operations on commercial banks, and happened to have views very close to today’s Modern Monetary Theory. Last, we trace back two interwar authors, Fernand Maroni and Robert Wolff, that were recently studied by Leonard (2024) as public finance theorists, and we show that their underlying theory of money was undoubtedly based on its endogeneity.
Area:
Keywords: Endogenous Money; Public Finance; Treasury; Treasury Circuit; Postkeynesianism; Modern Monetary Theory; France;
Please Login in order to download this file