Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Imagination and Its Impact on the Labor Market : A Smithian interpretation of adolescents’ future-oriented cognitions

akdere Çιnla Akdere, Assistant professor
Akdere Cinla, Assistant professor

According to L. Montes (2003), Adam Smith’s work in economics trapped between the concepts of self-interest and sympathy. Moreover, many concepts and arguments in his writings are often ignored on the assumption that they have no impact on his general arguments. Only a limited number of studies have focused on the notion of imagination in Smith’s work (Horne, 1981; Hausken, 1996; Sugden, 2002; Aydinonat, 2006; Wight, 2007; Walraevens, 2011; Bréban 2012, 2014, 2017; Witzum, 2023; Jaffro, 2024; Bréban & Jaffro, 2025). In The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759), the word “imagination” appears thirty-two times. There is also a more specific discussion of the central place of imagination in Smith’s moral philosophy, and particularly in sympathy (Evensky, 2005, I, 1, pp. 3–9; Harrison, 1995; Campbell, 1971; Skinner, 1974, 1979, pp. 14–41; Raphael, 2007). Imagination can be considered an internal resource of the individual, though not in the sense of the mechanism that connects people to past motives and feelings in order to draw inferences from their past actions (see Bénabou and Tirole, 2004). It is another motivation that shapes the future. From Smith’s work, a theory of personal identity based on imagination can be developed. In other words, even when individuals have no clear knowledge of the skills, dexterities, and talents that will shape their role in markets, by imagining an identity they make intertemporal choices in the labor market. But for A. Witztum (2023, p. 25), Smith’s positive theory of ethics does not deal with what is right or just, but rather with how people arrive at such judgments. These judgments are closely related to the behavior of others, since individuals are always situated within a social context. A growing body of work has explored adolescents’ future-oriented cognitions, current activities, and later educational attainment (Nurten Karacan Özdemir & Yusuf Cihat As, 2022; Sarah J. Beal & Lisa J. Crockett, 2010; N. Kahraman, 2022; Jay W. Rojewski, 2007; Thierry Rocher & Noémie Le Donné, 2012; Virginie Dupont & Dominique Lafontaine, 2017; Virginie Dupont, Christian Monseur, Dominique Lafontaine & Annick Fagnant, 2012; P. Dionne, A. Simard & S. Bourdon, 2019; Magdalena Piorunek, 2007). These qualitative and exploratory case studies investigate the career values and occupational aspirations of adolescent girls and boys, as well as those their parents hold for their children’s futures. Imagining the future self is therefore a matter of interest for the labor market. What is possible for a teenager within that market? At the same time, it is an educational problem: how to orient children and adolescents so that they may find occupations that correspond to their skills, talents, and interests. Where, and how, does a child or adolescent imagine himself or herself in the future? This paper aims to translate these internal human mechanisms into the economic sphere through the lens of Adam Smith’s work.

Area:

Keywords: Adam Smith, imagination, skill, intertemporal choices, adolescents

Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.