Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

"Theoretical Critique and ‘Experimentum crucis’: What Do Maurice Allais's Archives Teach Us About the 'Paradox'?"

FEREY Samuel, BETA-CNRS University of Lorraine
Dorian JULLIEN, Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne - Centre d'Economie de la Sorbonne

The Maurice Allais Archives are currently private archives, preserved and organized by his daughter, Christine Allais. They cover the entirety of his career. The archives dedicated to his work on the "paradox" contain a wealth of material: proofs of Maurice Allais’s presentation at the Paris colloquium, correspondence with the editors of Econometrica regarding the publication of his critique of the postulates and axioms of the American school, originals of the initial questionnaire proposed by Allais to colloquium participants, modified questionnaires received after the colloquium, letters refusing to respond to the questionnaires (from Émile Borel and Oskar Morgenstern), and various correspondences. This material, made accessible for the special session of the 8th International Colloquium on Economic Philosophy by Maurice Allais’s heir, sheds light on many elements already discussed by historians and philosophers (Jallais and Pradier, Mongin). More specifically, it is known that during the 1952 Paris colloquium, Maurice Allais criticized the axiomatics of expected utility theory from a theoretical standpoint. He supplemented his theoretical critique with an initial questionnaire to demonstrate that the behavior of a rational and prudent individual does not conform to this theory. Following the colloquium, faced with resistance from expected utility theorists, Allais published his contribution in Econometrica—despite relatively strong conflicts with co-editor M. Simpson, which required the intervention of Ragnar Frisch. He also refined, in his own words, his "survey" and developed a second, much more substantial questionnaire, which he sent by mail to a group of correspondents whom Allais considered particularly rational and knowledgeable about probability calculus (including Malinvaud, Massé, Hermitte, Morgenstern, and Borel). It was not until the 1970s that Maurice Allais fully utilized the results of these questionnaires. In this contribution, we will primarily focus on the meaning Maurice Allais attributed to the questionnaire responses. Three scenarios emerge: questionnaires received and analyzed by Allais; questionnaires received but set aside by Allais; and questionnaires left unanswered due to his correspondents’ refusal to participate. We will first seek to understand why Allais employed this particular method, characterized by the selection of specific subjects (Mongin 2014)—individuals whom Allais deemed particularly rational and well-versed in probability calculus. The study of the archives reveals how Allais reasoned as a physicist. For him, theoretical opposition could be resolved through a crucial experiment. Initially, this was a thought experiment developed in response to critical comments on Savage’s axioms (regarding the certainty effect, Allais wrote: "How can one experimentally determine whether this is actually the case? [...] We propose to conduct this experiment, which seems crucial to us," Intervention by M. Allais on the axioms of Messrs. Neumann, Savage, etc., May 16, 1952, afternoon, p. 3, Source: Private Archives of Maurice Allais). It later became an actual experiment conducted through the distribution of questionnaires: "I have just finalized a questionnaire to crucially test the behavior toward risk of individuals who can be assumed to act rationally. Thus, I hope that the opposing viewpoints can be definitively resolved" (Letter to Hermitte, June 27, 1952, Source: Private Archives of Maurice Allais). However, the letters of refusal—such as Morgenstern’s—challenged the experimental nature of this approach. Therefore, even before any theoretical opposition, the aim of this contribution is to demonstrate that there was a misunderstanding regarding the very meaning of "experiment" between Allais and his American critics. While one might contest the questionnaire as an experiment if it is seen as an attempt to refute an empirical theory, these criticisms are much weaker if the questionnaire is viewe

Area:

Keywords: Allais paradox, experiment, decision theory, archives

Please Login in order to download this file