Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

The Coercive Market and the Political Limits of Economic Autonomy in Ellen Meiksins Wood

Brunazzi Gianmaria, Università degli Studi di Milano

The paper revisits the work of Ellen Meiksins Wood on the tenth anniversary of her death to investigate the historical relationship between the economic and the political in capitalism. Widely recognized as a foundational figure of the political Marxist tradition, Wood is best known for her reinterpretation of the transition to capitalism and for her critique of teleological and market-centered narratives of capitalist development. While her work has been extensively discussed by historians and political theorists, it has rarely been engaged from the perspective of the history of economics (a partial exception is Clara Mattei’s The Capital Order), particularly with regard to its implications for the conceptualization of the market and for the historical conditions under which economics comes to appear as an autonomous field of knowledge and practice. In Wood’s analysis, the capitalist market is not founded on an ontological separation between economic and political spheres; rather, it is the historical mechanism through which that separation is produced. By treating surplus appropriation as the organizing principle of social reproduction, Wood identifies a radical break between the capitalist market and earlier forms of exchange. In pre-capitalist societies, markets offered opportunities within a broader political order: economic gains rested on privilege, arbitrage, and rent, generating predominantly price-inflating dynamics. The capitalist market, by contrast, is constituted as an inescapable social space. As the sole means of access to the conditions of subsistence and social reproduction, successful participation in the market becomes a condition of survival, imposing competitive imperatives that govern economic behavior and social order. This transformation rests on a reconfiguration of the relationship between the economic and the political. Whereas surplus appropriation previously relied on a direct and im-mediate combination of economic and political power, political authority now primarily secures the pervasive expansion of the market itself, which operates as a generalized structural constraint governing economic behavior and rendering appropriation intelligible as an apparently economic and voluntary relation. The conditions of possibility of modern economics as a science thus emerge not as natural or neutral, but as the historical outcome of this specific configuration of politically constructed market dependence. Engaging Wood’s analysis in dialogue with dominant economic conceptions of the market, the paper argues that the autonomy of economics falters not through political interference, but when the political conditions sustaining the universal reach of the capitalist market weaken. When market-mediated appropriation proves insufficient—whether due to inter-state or intra-state contradictions of accumulation—direct political domination re-emerges in visible forms, including politically constructed rents, privileges, coercive abuses, and imperialist violence. The crisis of economic principles in such contexts is therefore not internal to economics nor the consequence of excessive politicization, but the symptom of a crisis in the political conditions that normally allow the capitalist market to function as a comprehensive mechanism of social regulation, thereby revealing its historically contingent foundations.

Area:

Keywords: Capitalist market; Economic autonomy; Political Marxism; Market dependence