The Corruption of Nature and the Government of Crisis in 19th Century Political Economy
Narratives of crisis modernize the science of political economy in the 19th century by making nature and the natural adversarial, intractable, and corrupt. In the 18th century, natural laws made Adam Smith’s system of freedom an effective way to distribute a social surplus—whether useful commodities like food or shelter, or the laboring class itself—in a way that helps grow that surplus. In the 19th century, beginning with Malthus, nature appears as the inevitable source of dearth and scarcity, an irresistible force of human reproduction doomed by the unyielding drag of subsistence. With nature no longer serving as the standard of the good, the just, or the right, distribution, welfare, even human survival became arduous political tasks, only partly aided by the economic machine. Scholars have discussed at length the role of nature in embodying 18th century enlightenment values of a benevolent, unified order of things and ideas. In the paper, I read Smith alongside Malthus, Ricardo, and Marx to show how the constitutional role of nature was replaced in these narratives of crisis with a prominent role for human government, either through state apparatuses or, more commonly, the capitalist system itself as its own closed set of constitutional forces.
Area:
Keywords: Adam Smith; Nature; Justice; Narratives of Crisis; Malthus; population