Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

The emergence of ecological economics: from Wittgenstein’s failure to the Von Neumann-Ramsey-Sraffa model and the marginalization of Georgescu-Roegen

matarasso pierre, CIRED CENTRE INTERNATIONAL DE RECHERCHE SUR L'ENVIRONNEMENT ET LE DÉVELOPPEMENT

This paper explores the historical and epistemological intersection between early 20th-century analytic philosophy and the birth of "process economics." We propose that the catalyst for technically realistic economic modeling—from the Ramsey-Sraffa collaboration to Von Neumann and Georgescu-Roegen—was a fundamental attempt to resolve the limits of formal logic (Wittgenstein, Russell). While early analytic philosophy struggled to represent the material world without ambiguity—notably failing to account for "material exclusion" and time—a brilliant circle of thinkers spanning Cambridge, Vienna, and Princeton sought a "logic of the material world." They introduced a framework derived from logical atomism where the atoms are now processes or activities. Von Neumann, in his 1937 general equilibrium model, introduced also "joint production" as a way to represent the wear-and-tear of capital funds. This formalization liberated economics from its compromise with differential equations—as noted by Debreu. Despite the theoretical validation by Debreu in his work on general equilibrium, and numerous practical sector applications (energy, transport cf. Koopmans and Dantzig), this Von Neumann-Ramsey-Sraffa paradigm was marginalized in macroeconomic modelling. The trajectory of Georgescu-Roegen epitomizes this conflict: by integrating the entropy law into this process-based formalism, he demonstrated "the limits to growth", at least theoretically, more implacably than the Club of Rome. Consequently, he was relegated from a considered economist to the fringes as "unorthodox." We analyze this eviction as a political limit imposed on economic thought to maintain the narrative of infinite growth through "smooth" differentiable models that ignore the discrete and irreversible nature of resource use, the consequences of pollution, and the structural evolution of capital. Finally, we show how reconnecting with the Whitehead "process metaphysics" allows for a structural consistency in the face of climate tipping points. Resisting current political pressures requires a return to the logic of material and physical constraint through time, where economic validity is strictly bounded by the biophysical constraints of the biosphere, the structural changes of capital (funds and stocks), and the stocks and flows of mineral resources and pollutions.

Area:

Keywords: Ecological Economics, Process Philosophy, Logical Atomism, Joint Production, Structural Evolution of Capital, Georgescu-Roegen, Von Neumann-Sraffa Paradigm, Whitehead

Please Login in order to download this file