Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Adam Smith’s Encounters in Geneva (1765–1766): The Duchesse d’Enville, Enlightenment Sociability, and a Republican Laboratory

Guerra-Pujol F. E. Guerra-Pujol, University of Central Florida
Alcouffe Alain, Université Toulouse Capitole

Adam Smith’s brief visit to Geneva between late 1765 and early 1766 has long been acknowledged but remains under-interpreted. Existing accounts focus either on Smith’s proximity to Voltaire or treat Geneva as a transitional stop between Smith’s more lengthy sojourns in Toulouse (Mar. 1764 to Oct. 1765) and Paris (Feb. to Oct. 1766). This paper, by contrast, offers a new reading of Smith’s Genevan interlude by identifying the Duchesse d’Enville as the central social and intellectual mediator through whom Smith encountered Genevan elites. Drawing on previously unused or insufficiently exploited evidence—-particularly contemporary descriptions of the gatherings she organized in Geneva and testimony drawn from the Bonstettiana—-we argue that her residence functioned as the principal site of Smith’s Genevan sociability. The paper reconstructs the Duchesse d’Enville’s Genevan milieu at a moment when the Republic was marked by political tension, scientific controversy, and unresolved debates surrounding Rousseau. Bonstetten’s vivid accounts of the parties, excursions, and conversations hosted by the duchess provide rare insight into the informal spaces where French, Genevan, and British actors interacted. When read alongside her documented exchanges with Charles Bonnet and Georges-Louis Le Sage, along with her close association with Théodore Tronchin, these sources reveal a dense network of intellectual sociability in which Smith himself most likely participated. We suggest that this setting, rather than Ferney or formal institutions (e.g. the Consistory and the Grand Council), was the primary environment in which Smith encountered and socialized with leading Genevans. This reconstruction is complemented by the well-documented Christmas dinner hosted by Lord and Lady Stanhope in December 1765, which offers one of the few fixed points in Smith’s Genevan itinerary. Taken together, the Stanhope dinner and the duchess’s gatherings delineate an Anglo-Genevan microcosm in which scientific debates (notably the Voltaire–Needham controversy), moral questions (such as the proper role of amour propre?), republican anxieties (the deliberate failure of the Grand Council to elect a single Syndic in January 1766), and even general gossip (Rousseau’s scandalous abandonment of his children) were negotiated through conversation rather than formal doctrine. Rousseau’s presence was felt less through direct engagement than as a background force shaping political and moral discourse. Rather than searching for direct intellectual influence, the paper advances a contextual interpretation: Geneva appears as a “republican laboratory” in which Smith observed self-regulating orders—-scientific, moral, and civic—-operating through sociability, moderation, and mutual scrutiny. We argue that this experience helps to contextualize Smith’s later emphasis on self-command and sympathy in the sixth edition of The Theory of Moral Sentiments, as well as his reflections on small republics, education, and spontaneous coordination in The Wealth of Nations. By explicitly linking Adam Smith, the Duchesse d’Enville, and the Bonstettiana, this paper opens a new perspective on Geneva’s role in Smith’s continental education.

Area:

Keywords: Adam Smith, Duchesse d’Enville, Enlightenment, Geneva, sociability

Please Login in order to download this file