Comparative Advantage as an Educational Explanatory Concept
Over the past quarter-century, research in the field of Ricardian international trade theory has witnessed groundbreaking progress. Especially the impact of the new reading of Ricardo's chapter “On Foreign Trade” by Ruffin (2002) and Maneschi (2004) was considerable, inspiring numerous studies (Aldrich 2004, Pullen 2006, Bernhofen and Brown 2018, Morales Meoqui 2021, etc.). However, the concept of comparative advantage is often taken for granted as the supreme achievement in international trade theory, with exceptions notwithstanding, and the interpretation of Ricardo’s “four numbers” has been regarded as the most crucial point of contention in the history of international trade theory. This paper aims to show that the concept of comparative advantage, which remains central in the history of international trade theory since Ricardo, is merely an educational explanatory concept rather than a theoretical one, and to present a scheme of the history of international trade theory that has displaced it from its central position. The paper will first show how the concept of comparative advantage has developed as a “didactically useful” tool. As Faccarello (2022) shows, it was in James Mill’s Elements (1821-26, written as a “school-book”) that Ricardo’s “ex-post approach” was transformed into the “ex-ante perspective” in a simple two-country two-good case. Both Samuelson (1969) and Krugman (1993) emphasised the importance of the principle of comparative advantage based on episodes of teaching it in the classrooms. The paper will next outline the problems with the educational explanatory concepts that they make sense in particularly straightforward examples, yet when faced with more complex situations, where they cannot even be properly defined, they are presented as though they could be used to interpret the complex realities of the economy. The concept of comparative advantage is precisely that; it can explain international trade well in two-country two-good case when limited to final goods, but it cannot even be defined when three or more countries are involved (the many-country many-good case) or when trade in intermediate goods is included (Deardorff 2005; Shiozawa 2017, 2018; Ianni 2025). The paper will lastly present a different view of the history of international trade theory since Ricardo not based on the concept of comparative advantage. It will be based on the cost-of-production theory of value (Tabuchi 2018, 2022), which is valid in the many-country many-good case and potentially compatible with trade in intermediate goods.
Area:
Keywords: comparative advantage, international trade, Ricardo, Mill, education
Please Login in order to download this file