Hayek on urban planning
A central element of Hayek’s works is his critique of central planning and his skepticism regarding the decisions made by large bureaucratic organisations. Hayek deals with the spatial and urban aspects of the issue at length in a single place, in the chapter on "Housing and Town Planning" in his work "The Constitution of Liberty." These ideas have not received much attention either in discussions of Hayek’s legacy or in the literature on planning theory. This study examines and elaborates on this question from both perspectives and compares Hayek’s ideas and influence with those of Jane Jacobs, who is much better known in urban studies literature. A common misunderstanding regarding Hayek is the claim that he opposed all forms of planning. However, according to Hayek, the debate is not about whether planning is necessary or not, but rather whether planning should be carried out centrally by a single authority for the entire economy or distributed among a large number of individuals. Hayek thus opposed central planning based on state ownership, and he opposed (although he considered it less harmful than the former) government plans for mixed economies, engineering-style planning, and general urban planning. In contrast, he considered organizational-level plans, coordinated by the market, to be natural and important, with certain frictions but more efficiently than any central planning body could achieve, and he considered individual-level planning by people to be a corollary of rational behaviour and supported neighbourhood planning within cities. However, he did not support real estate development controlled by regulations and individual decisions through the elimination of the market and the price mechanism. According to Hayek, this engineering and architectural approach fails to understand the role of the price system in coordinating individual behaviour. Hayek’s approach, which supports neighbourhood planning and opposes large-scale planning, stands in sharp contrast to the engineering-based styles of urban planning of his time, but is in line with the views of Jane Jacobs, who wrote about the subject in much greater detail, as her 1961 book was devoted entirely to this topic. Jacobs does not refer to Hayek, only to Warren Weaver’s theory of complexity, which Hayek also refers to, but she comes to the same conclusion that the scattered information among individuals, termed “locality knowledge” by Jacobs, is not transferable to urban planning authorities. While Hayek had no influence on urban planning ideology and practice, Jacobs' very similar ideas had a fertile effect and she had a significant influence on urban planning, contributing to the development of a new urban construction paradigm.
Area:
Keywords: Hayek, planning history, urban planning, urban economics
Please Login in order to download this file