Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

An history of British economic thought on women’s role in the well-being and progress

Virginie Gouverneur, Université de Haute-Alsace

The project is an article issued from a book currently being written, the purpose of which is to trace the history of British economic and philosophical thought on the role of families and women in the increase of well-being and the progress. The article summarizes the elements that address two major issues in the book; while these elements are divided into two parts, they together highlight the decisive role played by the definition of the boundaries of political economy (economics) in the evolution of economists’ treatment of women’s issues. The first part aims to highlight and explain a shift that took place in the thought on families and women in political economy during the 1870s and 1880s. It takes the opposite view to theories suggesting continuity in the treatment of women’s issues in the history of political economy from Adam Smith to the neoclassical economists. To shed light on this shift, it reviews the approaches of three economists in particular, John Stuart Mill, William Stanley Jevons and Alfred Marshall, on three major themes: the wage gap between men and women, the traditional sexual division of labor in the family, and the economic valuation of unpaid domestic work. While Mill was a great defender of women’s freedom to choose their own lives, his commitment drawing on both utilitarianism and utopian socialism, the early marginalists Jevons and Marshall advocated restrictive measures to compel women to fulfil their natural duties related to the function of reproduction. The differences between the three economists on the role of families and women in the increase of well-being and the progress are analyzed in relation to the differences in the context in which each evolved as well as in their economic and philosophical theories. Based on the same method, the second part examines the effects of the emergence of welfare economics on the thought on families and women in economics in the first half of the 19th century. It draws on the work of two economists in particular, Marshall and Arthur Cecil Pigou, as founders of welfare economics with distinct visions of the boundaries of economics and its objects – including, in particular, the increase in well-being (Marshall), or welfare (Pigou). Another aim of this second part is to examine in fine the virtual disappearance of analyses of the family and women in economics from the interwar period to the 1970s, with the arrival of Gary Becker’s analyses.

Area:

Keywords: gender inequalities, utilitarianism, welfare economics

Please Login in order to download this file