Friedrich Hayek and Hans Kelsen: Dividing Lines of the Two Great Masters
Friedrich Hayek and Hans Kelsen: Dividing Lines of the Two Great Masters Yukihiro IKEDA Among the researchers of history of legal, political and economic thought, it is well-known that Hayek was basically a good friend of natural laws. In his major works, he emphasized that it is sometimes necessary to go beyond the narrow border of written laws and to think about the surroundings of these laws that make it possible to arrive at the mutual understanding and finally at the common interpretation and persecution of the laws. This idea obviously is diametrically opposed to the Kelsenian emphasis on the written, positive laws. In this presentation, after taking a brief look at the biography of the two great thinkers, I attempt to dig into the details of the differences between the two. Surrounding backgrounds of the two are nowadays available thanks to the efforts of Caldwell/Klausinger, Dekker, among others. Then, I scrutinize their arguments and mutual critical comments to each other. Some tentative conclusions are: 1. As is always indicated in the previous literature, Hayek was certainly a friend of natural laws, whereas Kelsen denied them. 2. Still there remains some ambiguities in Hayek’s understanding of laws. In some parts of different works, he emphasized the importance of written, definite laws, which leads to the decrease in the uncertainty of society. I am not quite sure whether this support of written laws a la continental tradition is compatible with his support for natural law. 3. Kelsen was confident that economic liberalism is quite different from the freedom of expression and of ideas. Obviously this is quite different from the Hayekian emphasis upon the close relationship of the two. In my view, those who still believe in the separability of the economic freedom and freedom of ideas continue to fail in their argumentation. In addition, this presentation will contribute to the more nuanced understanding of Hayek, rather than sticking to the traditional image of a scholar believing in natural law.
Area:
Keywords: Friedrich Hayek, Hans Kelsen, Natural Law
Please Login in order to download this file