Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Interdisciplinary collaborations and the emergence of mathematical economics at Stanford

Assaf Matheus, Universidade de São Paulo

Contemporary economics is characterized by a high level of insularity compared to other social sciences. Although the formalist turn in twentieth-century economics contributed to such insularity, historians of economics have pointed out that the emergence of mathematical economics in the postwar period was carried out by researchers coming from multiple disciplinary backgrounds, thus being itself a type of interdisciplinary effort. This paper explores how the interdisciplinary character of mathematical economics contributed to its expansion and dissemination within academic communities in the postwar period. The article focuses on the links between the expansion of the behavioral sciences at Stanford in the 1950s and the emergence of a strong community of mathematical economists in the Department of Economics. The paper begins by examining how interdisciplinary spaces were a key element in the early years of economics at Stanford. The Department of Economics initially occupied a secondary role in the university's internal pecking order, but the creation of the Food Research Institute during the interwar period boosted statistical research in economics on campus. The rising interest in statistics across various departments in the 1920s led to the creation of an interdisciplinary committee to organize a minor on the subject, chaired by a member of the Department of Economics. The first classes in mathematical economics at Stanford were offered as an advanced subject for those pursuing a minor in statistics in the 1930s. In the immediate postwar period, the department of economics underwent a profound restructuring following the retirement of a substantial group of professors in the late 1940s. In this context, Kenneth Arrow received a joint appointment in economics and statistics as a specialist in mathematical economics. However, economics remained a secondary discipline at Stanford, and the department operated on a tight budget and maintained a relatively small number of professors. Nevertheless, the rise of the interdisciplinary program of the behavioral sciences in the 1950s enabled Arrow to engage with a dynamic research group in mathematical economics. A key institution in this context was the Institute for Mathematical Studies in the Social Sciences (IMSSS), a research center in economics, mathematics, and psychology led by Arrow, Samuel Karlin, and Patrick Suppes. Founded in 1956 and funded by the Ford Foundation’s Behavioral Science Program, the IMSSS brought together scholars from those disciplines to develop behavioral theory and to promote mathematical education to social scientists. Research pursued at the IMSSS included mathematical programming, operations research, general equilibrium theory, and mathematical learning theory. The thin disciplinary boundaries within the IMSSS, supported by a shared mathematical epistemology, encouraged non-economists to make contributions to economic theory while working at the institute. The paper then examines how this dynamic context in the behavioral sciences attracted a large group of Stanford’s economics graduate students to research in mathematical economics within the department in the early 1960s. The article argues that the interdisciplinary environment of the IMSSS was fundamental to Stanford’s Department of Economics flourishing into a prominent center of research in general equilibrium theory in the postwar period.

Area:

Keywords: history of mathematical economics, history of economics departments, history of economics in the XXth century, Stanford, interdisciplinarity