Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Political economy and slave labor in Brazil: different perspectives within a colonial economy

COUTINHO MAURICIO, UNICAMP
Londe Silva Ana Paula, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais

Slave labor was one of the most critical issues in the Brazilian economic debates from the late colonial period through early independence. The Brazilian economy was based on slave labor; indeed, the African slave trade continued until 1850, and slavery was only abolished in 1888. From 1808 until 1821, the Portuguese court was settled in Rio de Janeiro, and Brazil became independent in 1822. Several Brazilian intellectuals studied at Coimbra, a traditional university modernized by reforms in the 1770s. In Portugal and Brazil, the intellectual and political milieu was influenced by Catholicism, and the Catholic tradition was dubious about slave labor, to say the least. The intellectuals educated in Coimbra were exposed to Enlightenment ideas, and at least from 1790 onward, Portuguese economic debates were influenced by physiocratic, Smithian, and even cameralist ideas. This intellectual and political background, in turn, was adapted to (and confronted with) the Brazilian reality: a rural economy (sugar cane), submitted until 1810 to the metropolitan exclusive, and pressures against the slave trade raised by the British from 1807. Britain's economic and political influence over Portugal, and after independence, over Brazil, was deep. Although well-versed in European Enlightenment traditions, few Brazilian economists shared the anti-slave labor sentiment that marked the late 1700s and early 1800s British and French intellectual mood. Smith, Say, and Sismondi were often invoked, but their anti-slavery stance barely penetrated the Brazilian economic debates. In this paper we will summarize and comment on the positions of three influential Brazilian intellectuals, who, from very different perspectives, debated slave trade and/or slave labor. These intellectuals, all educated in Coimbra, include J.J. Azeredo Coutinho (1742-1821), José Bonifácio de Andrada e Silva (1763-1838), and Hipólito J. da Costa (1774-1823). While Azeredo Coutinho was a strong supporter of the slave trade, Andrada e Silva defended its end and proposed a curious scheme for changing the country’s workforce. Hipólito da Costa, who lived in London, commented on the British position on slave trade. By examining the position of these influential intellectuals, we aim to show that their texts evidence a blend of intellectual and religious arguments, appealing to renowned economists and accounts of international travelers.

Area:

Keywords: slave labor, slave trade, colonization, Brazil

Please Login in order to download this file