Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

From the Superiority of Present Goods to Surplus Value: Ambiguity in Böhm-Bawerk’s Interest Theory

Potuzak Pavel, Prague University of Economics and Business

In contemporary Austrian interest theory, particularly within the framework of the pure time preference theory (PTPT), a fundamental ambiguity persists concerning the very object of explanation. It is often unclear whether interest is conceived as a real phenomenon—an intertemporal exchange ratio between present and future goods—or as a nominal phenomenon, namely a value difference between the value of invested inputs and the value of resulting output expressed in monetary terms. This paper argues that this ambiguity is not merely a problem of modern interpretation but is already present in the original writings of Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk. Based on a close textual analysis of Capital and Interest and The Positive Theory of Capital, the paper shows that Böhm-Bawerk alternates between two analytically distinct conceptions of interest. On the one hand, he frequently formulates interest as a real phenomenon: a systematic premium of present goods over future goods of the same kind and quantity, reflected in their intertemporal exchange ratio. On the other hand, he repeatedly defines the problem of interest as the emergence of “surplus value,” that is, a value excess of output over the value of consumed capital—a formulation that corresponds to a nominal concept of interest. These two approaches are not equivalent and may generate divergent theoretical conclusions. The paper further demonstrates that modern proponents of PTPT implicitly adopt the nominal interpretation of interest when they identify interest with the value difference measured in money and attribute its origin exclusively to time preference. Using a simple intertemporal model with production and money, it is shown that the nominal interest rate may be zero when the real interest rate is positive, and conversely, depending on price dynamics and the intertemporal elasticity of substitution. Consequently, the nominal interest rate cannot, in general, be identified with pure time preference alone. The main conclusion is that Austrian interest theory suffers from a conceptual inconsistency whose roots extend back to Böhm-Bawerk himself. If interest theory is to serve as a general equilibrium theory, interest must be treated primarily as a real phenomenon, while nominal interest and value surpluses should be regarded as derivative outcomes shaped by monetary conditions and price dynamics rather than as the core phenomenon to be explained by the theory.

Area:

Keywords: Austrian theory of interest; pure time preference theory; real versus nominal interest; Böhm-Bawerk; intertemporal exchange

Please Login in order to download this file