Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Weakening Economics: The Applied Turn, Pragmatism, and the Future of the Discipline

Cedrini Mario Aldo, Università di Torino
Erasmo Valentina, Università di Torino
Ambrosino Angela, Università di Torino
Davis John B., Marquette University and University of Amsterdam

The paper speculates about the potential evolution of the discipline of economics, focusing on the "applied turn" and its implications for the discipline's structure and theoretical foundations. The main idea comes from Spash's (2013) view of ecological economics as a field increasingly dominated by "new environmental pragmatists", who prioritize usability and immediate policy relevance over theoretical development, diluting the revolutionary potential of heterodox approaches by gradually accommodating neoclassical frameworks. We argue that the pattern observed in ecological economics and other peripheral fields (like feminist economics) may mirror a broader disciplinary shift – an “applied turn” – documented by Backhouse and Cherrier (2017), driven by both supply factors (new computational techniques, data availability, big data) and demand factors (changing institutional patrons, policy regimes, and private sector requirements). The relationship between interdisciplinary openness and the applied turn appears non-coincidental. The era of "reverse imperialisms" contrasts with traditional economics imperialism, as specialization encourages exploration of paradigmatic anomalies, prompting economics to seek assistance from other disciplines. Su and Colander (2021) emphasize that "scientific economics" requires other disciplines to become "applied political economy" in this applied era. The metaphors characterizing the literature on the applied turn—economists as engineers, plumbers, physicians—reveal economics' recognition of its own insufficiency. Yet, proposals to adapt the economics profession to the new societal challenges (globalization, AI, and the like), like Duflo’s (2017) encouraging economists to become plumbers, appear simultaneously too strong (presuming economists can acquire competencies they lack) and too weak (failing to address economic theory's fate). Meanwhile, the critique of pragmatism by social ecological economists seems excessively present-focused, overlooking how pragmatism simultaneously pressures mainstream economics to accept previously rejected elements, further compressing orthodox theory (at a time when “useful” knowledge takes precedence over theoretical perspectives). In other words, the applied turn provides economics an opportunity to weaken the rigid core-periphery hierarchy that has long characterized it, but only if supported by the development of flexible yet general theoretical frameworks (like the transdisciplinary alliance between economics and engineering invoked by Mariotti 2021, 2022) that can counteract the risk that theory's decline may produce merely reductive tinkering. In an era where technology reveals the illusory nature of claims to scientific certainty (Vattimo 2000), pragmatists and neo-pragmatist philosophy can contribute to constructing such frameworks—"redescriptions" (à la Rorty) that enable productive interdisciplinary collaboration.

Area:

Keywords: Economics as a discipline; Pragmatism; Applied turn; Pluralism; Engineering

Please Login in order to download this file