Collective Agreements as the Preconditions of Freedom: Fukuda Tokuzō’s Social Policy Liberalism
This paper reinterprets Fukuda Tokuzō’s theory of collective agreements (labor agreements) not as a corrective technique imposed upon the principle of freedom of contract, but as a core institutional component of what may be termed social policy liberalism. Against prevailing interpretations that regard labor agreements as either exceptions to private law autonomy or as instruments of state intervention replacing market mechanisms, this study argues that Fukuda conceived collective agreements as a necessary precondition for the realization of free competition itself. Fukuda’s problem awareness originated in the structural failure of individual labor contracts under conditions where labor functions as a future-delivery commodity inseparable from human personality. In such circumstances, formal contractual freedom produces only asymmetrical bargaining and fictitious competition. Drawing critically on the labor theory of Anton Menger and the economic arguments of Lujo Brentano, Fukuda reformulated the concept of the right to subsistence (existence right) not as a distributive or relief-oriented social right, but as a foundational condition enabling workers to participate in collective bargaining as genuine market actors. Within this framework, collective agreements emerge as institutions that restore symmetrical price formation through collective bargaining, thereby transforming labor into a “real” commodity capable of entering competitive exchange. Importantly, Fukuda did not envisage state intervention as a substitute for market freedom; rather, the state was assigned the role of constructing the institutional and legal foundations upon which free competition could meaningfully operate. By situating Fukuda’s thought in dialogue with German collective labor law theory, British collective bargaining practices, and later postwar Japanese labor law scholarship, this paper demonstrates that Fukuda anticipated a conception of labor law as the precondition of freedom rather than its limitation. The study concludes that Fukuda’s social policy liberalism represents a distinctive theoretical attempt to reconstruct liberalism from within, redefining freedom not as the absence of regulation but as a condition institutionally sustained through social rights and collective agreements.
Area:
Keywords: Collective Agreements, Right to Subsistence, Social Policy Liberalism
Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.