Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

David Hume on authority and commerce

Arthmar Rogerio, UFRN, UFES, CNPq
Castañeda Juan, Vinson Centre, The University of Buckingham

Although Hume’s History of England third and fourth volumes on the Tudors focus on royal authority and religious strife, it contains a significant array of reflections on the state of British industry and commerce during an epoch of heavy legal restraints. After an introduction to the subject, the paper’s second section outlines the main elements uniting Hume’s philosophical inquiries with his approach to historical composition, combining, on the one hand, the contingency of passions with the people’s conformity to tradition and, on the other, the tension between authority and liberty defined by the interplay of domestic and external forces. The third section covers the reign of Henry VII, showing how, according to Hume, the sovereign worked to dismantle the armed muscle of feudal power, forcing the bellicose retainers to leave the countryside and strive for a more diligent life in villages and towns. The faint but persistent forward procession of commerce, along with the retreat of internal conflicts, seduced the land barons into sumptuary habits of consumption, creating a demand for urban craftsmanship, which ultimately destabilised the feudal chains of servitude. But as Henry VII’s power grew without dissent, so did his readiness to regulate not only the political world, but also the economic relations within the kingdom, to the detriment of manufactures and trade, whose true development, for Hume, required full freedom of movement instead. The fourth section covers Henry VIII’s despotic years, a time which Hume considered the worst for the plan of liberty in Britain due to the King’s willingness, always supported by parliament, to grant monopolies of all sorts and reinforce the hold of corporations over labour. Advances, however, were registered by a more efficient administration of justice, a peaceful resolution of religious dissent, and the reinforcement of property rights. The fifth section looks into the long reign of Elizabeth I, which spanned the entire fourth volume of Hume’s History. The restoration of the Protestant faith, one learns there, benefited the kingdom by its welcoming of Flemish and French Huguenots fleeing persecution, who brought to the island their refined skills in artisanship and trade. In parallel, argued Hume, Elizabeth I’s heavy-handed treatment of the Puritans turned them into the most active zealots for religious and political freedom, foreshadowing the shift in parliamentary posture against royal authority after the Queen’s demise. The concluding remarks weave together the domestic and external long-run forces, especially in their economic effects, making for the ascendancy, but also the zenith, of absolute power in Britain over the Tudor period in Hume’s interpretation.

Area:

Keywords: authority, liberty, trade, manufactures, Tudor period

Please Login in order to download this file