Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

At the Crossroads of Welfare Economics: Atkinson and the Making of an Inequality Measure.

Álvarez Andrés, Universidad de Los Andes - Bogota
Jacob Eva, Visiting Scholar at the Center for the History of Political Economy, Duke University

This paper revisits Anthony B. Atkinson’s contribution to the measurement of income inequality by situating his 1970 article, On the Measurement of Inequality, at a crossroads in the history of economic thought. Rather than treating the Atkinson index as a self-contained technical innovation or as a straightforward revival of earlier normative traditions, we reconstruct the intellectual process through which Atkinson’s approach emerged from the convergence of distinct, mutually reinforcing lines of influence during the late 1960s. We first place Atkinson within the Cambridge tradition of welfare economics, understood beyond the canonical Pigou–Dalton lineage. The transfer principle and the idea that inequality measurement is tied to social evaluation provide a background, but we emphasize how James Meade and Peter Townsend shaped Atkinson’s early engagement with poverty, inequality, and the distributive consequences of policy. In parallel, we highlight Frank Hahn’s role in Atkinson’s exposure to an axiomatic conception of economic theory and to a methodological setting in which normative questions were expected to be stated with analytical discipline. We then examine the influence of the Bergson–Samuelson social welfare function framework. For Atkinson, this framework supplied a formal language for stating explicitly the distributional value judgments embedded in welfare comparisons—most directly, the inequality-aversion parameter that fixes how marginal social value of income varies across the distribution—rather than leaving those judgments implicit. This move matters for interpretation: the index is constructed to track welfare-relevant distributional comparisons under stated evaluative premises, not to provide a purely descriptive summary of dispersion. The paper also draws on archival evidence from the Anthony Atkinson Papers at Duke University’s Rubenstein Library to recover a technical line of work that is rarely connected to the 1970 article. We analyze an unpublished manuscript written in response to Weisbord and Hansen (1968) in which Atkinson explored the relationship between income as a flow and wealth as a determinant of income-generating capacity. We argue that this work clarifies the object of measurement that Atkinson sought to summarize within a welfare-consistent framework, and the informational choices implied by treating “income” as a basis for aggregation. Finally, we reconstruct the formative role played by Joseph E. Stiglitz. Atkinson’s early exposure to decision theory under uncertainty—first through Stiglitz’s supervision in Cambridge, encouraged by Hahn, and later through interaction at MIT—shaped his use of certainty equivalents and attitudes toward risk as an analytical analogue for inequality aversion. This channel helps explain why On the Measurement of Inequality explicitly mobilizes results from choice under uncertainty: it provides a bridge between welfare economics and inequality measurement through a common logic of equivalent, welfare-preserving transformations.

Area:

Keywords: Inequality, Welfare Economics, Anthony Barnes Atkinson.

Please Login in order to download this file