[YSP] Models as a New Framework of Thought. Reading the Production of Ignorance through Stigler’s Theory of Search Costs
This paper aims to show to what extent Stigler’s theory of search-cost (Stigler, 1961, 1962) to describe and provide a renewed analysis of phenomena related to the production of ignorance. Research on the production of ignorance seeks to document practices aimed at generating doubt (or ignorance) regarding social, environmental, or health-related issues. These practices are often carried out by commercial actors seeking to absolve their products from accusations that may be raised against them. A well-known example is the tobacco industry, which implemented a strategy of ignorance production in response to studies establishing a link between tobacco consumption and the development of cancer. This strategy consisted in promoting alternative studies on cancer that emphasized the role of other factors (such as heredity, lifestyle, etc.). Highlighting alternative potential causes of cancer thus served as a strategy for the tobacco industry to defend the harmlessness of its products (Proctor, 2014). The production of ignorance therefore consists in obscuring the link between the consumption of a good and its effects on individuals or society. Through a specific case, the aim of this contribution is to show that it may be fruitful to mobilize models from economic theory in order to shed light on phenomena that have been studied and documented by other disciplines. Such an approach raises three types of issues, which this contribution seeks to identify and clarify. From the perspective of economic analysis, Economics has so far paid little attention to the challenges currently faced by scientific research. Mobilizing its various models offers a way to assess what it can contribute to ongoing discussions. Insofar as research on ignorance production has shown that the proliferation of scientific results may hinder the establishment of new knowledge on complex issues, it raises practical and theoretical questions about knowledge accumulation. From the perspective of understanding ignorance-production phenomena, the objective is to propose an original representation of certain aspects of ignorance production through specific models. While studying complex and multidimensional phenomena through models that retain only stylized facts may appear limiting, the aim is to show that ignorance studies may benefit from a certain analytical segmentation. From the standpoint of economic philosophy, this contribution raises the question of the possibility and the relevance of reusing models to apprehend situations arising in different contexts. The approach thus resembles a transfer of models from one discipline to another, accompanied by an examination of its epistemic effects. The contribution also has a historiographical dimension, insofar as it seeks to show that the correspondence between the model and the object it is used to describe is not accidental, but rather the result of a certain "ideological affinity". This paper focuses on Stigler’s search-cost model and its contemporary extensions. This model belongs to the economic theories of information. By weighing the costs of searching for new information against the potential benefits such information may bring, individuals determine their optimal level of search. The trade-off is framed in monetary termes : time or transportation costs vs. saved expenditures. The production of ignorance can thus be understood as a strategy of obstruction that increases individuals’ information search costs. By making information more difficult to process or by disseminating preselected information, ignorance production alters the structure of search costs. It leads individuals to make information-processing choices that differ from those they would have made in the absence of ignorance production. The production of ignorance thus ultimately affects individuals’ welfare.
Area:
Keywords: Stigler, Ignorance, Information, Model Transfer, Knowledge
Please Login in order to download this file