The Professionalization of Economic History in the United States: The Economic History Association and the Committee on Research in Economic History
This article examines the creation of the Economic History Association (EHA) and the Committee on Research in Economic History (CREH), analysing their roles in the professionalization of economic history in the United States during the 1940s. Although both institutions were established almost at the same moment and involved many of the same scholars, they performed distinct functions and embodied different approaches to defining and consolidating the field. By analyzing these institutions comparatively, the article shows how they reflected broader debates over the scope, methods, and intellectual foundations of economic history. Founded in 1940, the Economic History Association emerged through a relatively rapid process of institutional consolidation. Despite competition from neighboring academic associations in economics, history, and the social sciences, the EHA succeeded in establishing itself as a central forum for economic historians. It brought together economists, historians, and other social scientists, promoting interdisciplinary exchange and providing a shared institutional identity. Through annual meetings and the creation of the Journal of Economic History, the Association offered a space for scholarly communication, professional recognition, and the circulation of research. In this sense, the EHA was important in securing the visibility and legitimacy of economic history within the American academic landscape. The Committee on Research in Economic History, by contrast, had a more difficult evolution. Committee was responsible for evaluating research proposals and allocating funding, which required defining what constituted economic history and determining which projects should receive institutional support. Discussions within the Committee reveal disagreements over fundamental issues, including the relationship between economic theory and historical analysis, the relative importance of national versus local studies, the role of primary historical sources, and the criteria by which scholarly quality and relevance should be assessed. These debates exposed competing visions of economic history and divergent expectations about the future direction of the field. The article argues that while the Economic History Association succeeded in fostering institutional cohesion and interdisciplinary dialogue, the Committee on Research in Economic History reflected the divergences within the field. Despite being directed by the same group of individuals, the two institutions embodied different dimensions of professionalization. The EHA facilitated collective identity and communication, whereas the Committee concentrated debates over methodological standards, research priorities, and disciplinary boundaries. Taken together, their contrasting trajectories illuminate the tensions, negotiations, and redefinitions that shaped economic history in the United States during the 1940s, highlighting professionalization as a process marked not only by institutional success but also by intellectual disagreement.
Area:
Keywords: Economic History; History of Economic Thought; History of Social Sciences
Please Login in order to download this file