Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

“Keynesian” in Hansard: A Quantitative Text Analysis of British Parliamentary Discourse during the Second and Third Crises of Economics

KOMINE Atsushi, Hosei University

(New Version)This paper examines how Keynesian economic thought circulated within British parliamentary discourse, focusing on the policy-making sphere rather than academia alone. Using Hansard-related databases, it analyzes references to “Keynes”, “Keynesian/s” and “Keynesianism”, especially during the second crisis of economics in the 1970s and the third crisis after the 2007 global financial crisis. The paper argues that Keynesianism should not be understood merely as an academic doctrine, but as a political language repeatedly invoked in moments of economic crisis. A key contrast is provided by monetarism-related terms. Although the surface frequency of monetarism-related terms declined sharply after the Thatcher period, their core ideas may have survived under other names, such as inflation targeting, price stability, or rules-based policy. By contrast, Keynesian-related discourse appeared across a wider range of cabinets and political contexts, with notable peaks in the early 1980s and early 2010s. This contrast suggests that Keynesianism retained a more durable and flexible political vocabulary. Methodologically, the paper uses quantitative text analysis, including frequency analysis and co-occurrence networks, as a heuristic route back to close reading. In this sense, Keynesian discourse emerges as a lasting “language of crisis” in British politics. (Old Version)Since the 1936 Revolution, Keynes’s ideas have repeatedly risen and fallen alongside the turbulence of capitalism. During the 1970s, intense criticism from both internal heterodoxy (Robinson 1972) and mainstream counter-revolution (the Lucas critique, 1976) profoundly challenged the assumption that policymakers could systematically steer the economy. Following the global financial crisis—the “third crisis of economics”—interest has again revived as a “Return to Keynes”. The long-term objective of this research project is to identify why Keynesian thought has remained useful over time and to clarify the conditions under which its influence re-emerges. We position Keynesian thought within the British tradition of maximally respecting economic efficiency, social justice, and individual liberty—that is, within the lineage of the New Liberalism. The project conceptualizes the diffusion of economic ideas across three interconnected spheres: academic discourse, policy-making arenas, and the public. This paper focuses on the second sphere, examining how Keynesian ideas were articulated within parliamentary discourse during periods of economic crisis. Specifically, the paper analyzes references to “Keynes” and “Keynesian” in the British Parliamentary Proceedings (Hansard), concentrating on two periods: 1980–84 (criticism of the welfare state under the Thatcher administration) and 2010–14 (rebuilding economics after the Lehman shock). The quantitative text analysis we employ visualizes not only the frequency of individual morphemes but also their co-occurrence patterns and groupings based on external variables. This enables us to clarify, with the support of numerical data and charts, the specific social contexts in which Keynesian ideas are referenced. The paper concludes by addressing when, by whom, and in what manner Keynesian doctrine—understood as an integration of theory, policy, and broader economic thought—was invoked during British economic crises. By extending this framework to comparative analysis of parliamentary debates in the United States, Japan, and Australia, the study opens avenues for future research on the international diffusion of Keynesian ideas.

Area:

Keywords: Keynesian Thought, Hansard, Quantitative Text Analysis, Crises of Economics, New Liberalism

Please Login in order to download this file