Re-examining the Responses to Henry Thornton’s 1802 Pioneering Ideas on Inconvertibility and Active Monetary Policy: From Horner to Hayek and Hicks
In the history of monetary thought Henry Thornton (1760-1815) stands out and is often considered as the "First and Foremost". During the first half of the nineteenth century, his 1802 book *Paper Credit* was well read by influential scholars, first by Francis Horner who famously reviewed the book and then by David Ricardo, Thomas Tooke and J. S. Mill. Surprisingly and famously, Thornton’s name disappeared from the literature around 1870, to be ‘rediscovered’ half a century later. He was then reinstated to the political economy literature, first by Jacob Viner in 1924, but more significantly by Friedrich von Hayek who was responsible in 1939 for the republication of Hayek’s 1802 monumental book, An Enquiry into the Nature and Effects of the Paper Credit of Great Britain, to which he wrote an elaborate Introduction. Thornton became even better known among mainstream economists later, owing to John Hicks’ 1967 article entitled "Thornton's Paper Credit". The paper will outline Thornton's principal doctrines, mainly based on his 1802 book, but also using other sources. It will then explore the readings of scholars, from Horner to Hayek and Hicks: How different their interpretations were, despite their consensus concerning Thornton’s being "innovative," and "ahead of his times". Thornton argued that, in principle, it is possible to have in society an inconvertible monetary system that could function properly. Furthermore, he thought that such a system has some advantages compared with the traditional convertible system based on the gold standard. His analysis emphasized the importance of Credits and Debts and addressed the balance of payments. The paper will explore the influence Thornton had on economists, particularly regarding his unique analysis of monetary policy when the system abandoned gold. This condition characterized the UK from 1797 to 1821 (the Restriction), i.e. when Paper Credit was written; it turned out to be the world common regime since the 1970s. Hence, economists could find Thornton’s pioneering analysis of inconvertibility in Paper Credit, as an early analysis of the modern monetary system. Thornton's innovative analysis of the macro-economy related to the balance of payments and to the financial system. Various authors who read him with admiration read him differently, appreciating some aspects of his analysis while ignoring, sometimes explicitly rejecting, others. Were they under the influence of the public image of Thornton (one of the three drafters of the Bullion Report that called for a return to gold) than by the seminal book he wrote? Were they selective, taking from Thornton what was in line with their own thinking, while ignoring what was not? Were they missing some of the main ideas because Thornton was not always lucid?
Area:
Keywords: History of Monetary Theory, Thornton, Monetary Policy, Central Banking, Gold Standard, Convertibility, Inconvertibility
Please Login in order to download this file