Walras’s distinction between the Ideal and the Real through his correspondence with Renouvier
Léon Walras’s particular conception of science has caused multiple interpretive problems for scholars. The most debated question concerns the epistemological status of the Éléments d’Économie Politique Pure and its general equilibrium model : positive theory of normative project ? Since the 1970s, an abundant literature has been devoted to this problem. A recent line of interpretation holds that the adjective “normative“ is inadequate to describe pure economics, given Léon Walras’s peculiar epistemology. Although pure economics describes what is, Walras is fundamentally anti-positivist, and his theory can hardly be described as “positive“ in the traditional sense either. If the opposition between positive and normative is ineffective for characterizing Walrassian science, another distinction is far more structuring : that between the Ideal and the Real. This contribution explores and clarifies the relation between the Real and the Ideal, which is crucial to understanding the Walrassian project. It is now clear that ontological and epistemological reflexions have been of upmost importance for Walras himself, and need to be taken into account for a correct interpretation of his theory. But little attention has been paid to this distinction, although it is the principal topic of discussion in the correspondence between Walras and the philosopher Charles Renouvier (1815-1903), as well as in the latter’s reviews of the Éléments and the Recherche de l’Idéal Social. These exchanges offer a better apprehension of Walras’s distinction between the Real and the Ideal and its connection with the different sciences that compose political and social economy. Moreover, they reveal Walras’s particular philosophical position : he distinguishes himself both from Renouvier’s neo-criticism and from his “mentor“, Étienne Vacherot (1809-1897), by affirming the possibility of a link between the sphere of the Ideal and the sphere of the Real. This link is carried through history and through human activity, which transforms imperfect reality in the strive toward the perfect ideal. This contribution will thus highlight the manner in which the distinction between the Ideal and the Real structures Léon Walras’s thought and scientific project, while also enabling us to rethink the traditional opposition between the positive and the normative.
Area:
Keywords: Léon Walras, Normativity, Ontology, Epistemology