Freedom and Clairvoyance: Ontological-Anthropological Foundations in Walrasian Political and Social Economy
This paper presents a systematic reconstruction of the philosophical anthropology underlying the work of Léon Walras, arguing that the twin pillars of free will and rational clairvoyance in his economic thought are neither incidental nor merely methodological. While previous scholarship (Walker 2000, Dockès1994, 1996) has noted the presence of human nature elements in Walras’s thought, these observations have remained fragmented and subordinate to other interpretive priorities, such as the role of mathematics. A dedicated, comprehensive analysis of his anthropological commitments—and their theoretical consequences—is lacking. This study fills that gap by demonstrating how a specific conception of human nature fundamentally structures Walrassian economics, providing the normative and conceptual foundation for his entire theoretical edifice, from pure theory to social reform. Guided by the central questions such as « What is the content and the coherence of Walrassian anthropology? », « How does it shape his core economic postulates? », the present analysis proceeds through two complementary lenses. First, an immanent analysis systematically examines Walras’s corpus to identify and synthesize his core anthropological tenets, particularly the axiomatic attribution of freedom and clairvoyance to the economic agent. This reconstruction then illuminates how these tenets underwrite his key methodological choices and theoretical constructs, including the conditions for tâtonnement and general equilibrium. Second, a genealogical analysis situates this reconstructed anthropology within its broader intellectual milieu. Moving beyond the recognized influences of Auguste Walras and Étienne Vacherot, the paper uncovers the decisive yet underappreciated imprint of the French Eclectic Spiritualist tradition, particularly the philosophies of Victor Cousin and Théodore Simon Jouffroy. The study’s central thesis is that Walras’s postulates of agent freedom and clairvoyance are not neutral, simplifying abstractions but are instead philosophically loaded postulates with deep ontological and epistemological roots. Consequently, the famed normativity of the Lausanne School—and by extension, a foundational strand of modern neoclassical economics—could be reinterpreted as the contingent outcome of a historical encounter between French spiritualist metaphysics and the nascent project of a mathematized social science. By adopting this anthropological-ontological perspective, this paper reveals the normative architecture embedded within the seemingly positive foundations of general equilibrium theory.
Area:
Keywords: Ontological anthropology, Walras, normative foundations, mathematics, Lausanne School, French Eclectic Spiritualism