Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Keynes's 'Autonomy of macroeconomics' principle

Togati Teodoro, University of Turin

In this paper, I focus on Keynes’s view that macroeconomics is an autonomous discipline with respect to standard theory. In particular, as his famous ‘right dichotomy’ argument shows, for Keynes the theory of output and employment as a whole should be sharply distinguished from the theory of the individual industry or firm and of the rewards and the distribution between different uses of a given quantity of resources. The contribution of this paper is twofold. First, it suggests that although Keynes affirmed this autonomy principle with respect to Marshallian micro theory, it also applies with respect to modern axiomatic general equilibrium theory (GET), which has fully carried out Lucas’s project to kill the autonomy of macroeconomics by reducing it to the ‘first principles’ of economics, i.e. choice theory. According to Keynes instead choice theory, while correct in itself, is not the canon of economics and should not be transferred from the analysis of individual units to the analysis of the system as a whole, as classical economists try to do. Second, the paper seeks to uncover Keynes’s full-blown ‘autonomy’ agenda. More specifically, it holds that the autonomy principle is multi-dimensional: it involves various features that should be carefully distinguished. While a number of such features have been adequately stressed in the enormous Keynesian literature (I refer, for example, to Keynes’s emphasis on various ‘fallacies of composition’, i.e. the invalid transfer of conclusions drawn for individuals to the aggregate level as revealed in particular by the paradox of thrift or early Keynesians’ attempt to build aggregate models without caring for ‘micro-foundations’), the paper underlies that many others have been quite neglected so far as they are not always clearly or fully articulated in Keynes’s writings. Here is a list of topics that can be regarded as being part of Keynes’s full-blown ‘autonomy’ agenda, that the paper focuses upon: a.Aggregate approach b.A truly systemic perspective c.Multiple levels of income d.Critical vs routine decisions e.Money and the ‘taste for freedom’ f.Asymmetries between demand and supply g.Focus on money prices h.High vs low inflation contexts i.Conventional value m.Focus on equilibrium at a point in time n.A ‘substantive’ stability analysis o.Non homogeneity of time p.Synchronic vs dynamics laws r.A ‘constrained’ approach to econometrics

Area:

Keywords: Keynes macroeconomics autonomy

Please Login in order to download this file