Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Public finances, credit, confidence and war: the debates between Souza Coutinho, Balbo, and Napione on the creation of the Banco di S. Secondo in the late-18th-century Turin

Cunha Alexandre, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais - UFMG
Fleider Marchevsky Julia, Universidade Estadual de Campinas

In 1793, an imminent French invasion loomed over the Savoy monarchy, increasing the pressure and urgency to raise financial resources to meet mounting military expenses required by the ongoing conflict with revolutionary France, which was disrupting the fragile balance of public finances in the Kingdom of Sardinia. In this context, some financial and economic experts exchanged intense correspondence, which ultimately aimed to support the financial restructuring measures developed by Count Pietro Graneri, then Secretary of State to Victor Amadeus III. Graneri’s proximity to the circle of diplomatic envoys in Turin fostered a debate in which prominent foreign diplomats were included in the search for solutions. At the suggestion of the British envoy, John Trevor, the Portuguese envoy, Rodrigo de Souza Coutinho, recognized among his peers as a leading expert on economic and financial matters, was promptly called upon to offer his views on the issue. Souza Coutinho’s reflections sparked a lively debate in which other Piedmontese experts from his circle of contacts, such as Prospero Balbo and Gian Franceso Napione, took part. Based on documentation preserved in the Archivio di Stato di Torino, it is possible to reconstruct this debate, whose central objective was to devise ways to increase the kingdom’s funds, especially through the creation of a national bank. These efforts ultimately led to the creation of the short-lived San Secondo Bank. The focus of the article is not the concrete results of the attempts to reorganize Sardinian finances, but rather the economic ideas debate surrounding the creation of a public bank in the period preceding the French revolutionary army’s incursions into Piedmont from 1794 onwards. The article thus explores the plurality of perspectives and financial projects around a particular issue that was absolutely fundamental at the time and had important repercussions for the history of economic ideas: whether a monarchy could directly issue paper money or needed an intermediary institution, such as a national bank. The problem involved defining which institutions could provide sufficient public confidence to sustain the acceptance and value of a financial instrument. Similarly, the debates reveal how a concern took shape to avoid more forceful means of increasing revenue or obtaining credit for the government, recognizing that establishing a climate of confidence required persuading private economic agents to participate in this effort to create a national bank. An examination of this debate based on the rich exchange of preserved correspondence reveals how the language of political economy was mobilized and used to influence the course of economic governance in the states during that tumultuous end of the 18th century.

Area:

Keywords: 18th century; Public finances; credit; public confidence; Enlightened Reformism; national banks; Italy; France; Portugal.

Please Login in order to download this file