Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Why wide-encompassing history of welfarism matters for revisiting welfare economics

BAUJARD Antoinette, Université Jean Monnet, GATE Lyon Saint-Etienne

I claim that history of economic thought and philosophy of economics can provide broader perspectives than the standard marginal process of scientific research does, and that those can help to imagine salutary improvements of economics per se. I here defend and illustrate this double claim by leveraging the history of the term “welfarism” to revisit welfare economics. “Welfarism” is a focus on utility (or more generally on welfare) to assess social states and help public decision making, but the exact meaning of the term evolves alongside welfare economics and its criticism. First, I show that some relevant tensions – e.g., regarding the articulation between positive and normative levels of analysis, or paternalism – can only be identified when considering and contrasting different historical moments, different disciplines, different perspectives, whether from public action or theory. Second, I highlight that two distinct categories of criticism were initially raised in Sen’s original definition: the information used in welfarist evaluations and the formal framework itself. I show that that welfare economics has gradually incorporated the informational issue, and is now potentially compatible with focusing on other values but utility – such as freedom, or multiple dimensions –, but that it continues to overlook major problems raised by the framework – such as the neglect of agency and individualism. Third, I conclude that the epistemic reliability of such broad narratives depends on the given benchmark and papers using other approaches.

Area:

Keywords: History of economic thought, Welfare economics, Social welfare, Welfarism, Utility, Agency

Please Login in order to download this file