Antonio Rosmini conception of individual action and the missed development of Italian Liberal-Catholic political economy
At the beginning of the XIX century, liberal-Catholic circles in France produced some work in political economy (Lamennais, DeCoux, Villeneuve-Bargemont), while similar circles in Italy (Rosmini, Manzoni) did not. The reasons may be due to the different context of lagged industrial development and to the different political trajectory. Nonetheless, Antonio Rosmini expressed a theory of individual action that has been seen as an anticipation of the Austrian perspective (Antiseri) and of phenomenology. Such theorisation of human action in society has been developed in Rosmini studies on anthropology and in political science. It also is the result of and interesting and sharp debate between Gioja and Romagnosi. The result is a conception of the individual emerging from both theology a variety of humanities as anthropological and philosophical studies. This conception includes also some characteristics that make it suitable for an economic theory of choice. Compared to the Austrian view, it had the advantage of a coherent conception including morals and a complex role of reason. Consequently, it allows to conceive a clear model incorporating a variety of ethical elements in decision making. It incorporated an idea of happiness as a self-consciousness of our own achievements compared to our ambitions. The end of man is happiness and it can be achieved in different ways, but it is not connected directly to the results of choices as to the self-reflection of man. All this was not incorporated into an economic theory even if Giuseppe Toniolo and the Padua school respected the views of Rosmini and in minimal part incorporated some insight in their practical approach to the economy. On the one hand, Rosmini and Turin’s liberals (Ferrara) had no convergence on morals and religion, on the other, the Church repressed Rosmini’s liberalism inhibiting other Catholics to follow that way. The paper first presents Catholic circles in France and in Italy and their economic-political views. Then the anthropology and political science of Rosmini is analysed to derive a unitary view of individual action. The latter will be compared with other approaches as the Austrian to understand its relevance. Finally, this theory will be put in its historical context to understand why it was not exploited.
Area:
Keywords: Theory of choice; happiness; self-consciousness
Please Login in order to download this file