Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Sismondi: happiness and utilitarianism

Pascal Bridel, Université de Lausanne

Pascal Bridel, Walras-Pareto Centre University of Lausanne In a series of previous articles, the author examined Sismondi’s concept of market and vision of the instability of a decentralised economy linked to his price theory (Bridel, 2021) as well as how money and the banking system reinforce this intrinsic instability (Bridel, 2023). The author attempted then to insert these main results into the Sismondian trilogy of freedom-wealth-happiness to connect more thoroughly social values and wealth (Bridel 2025). Since Sismondi considers market coordination as dysfunctional, the synchronic order just does not work. In parallel, it was also shown why and how Sismondi finds this failed coordination mechanism morally unacceptable: the diachronic order is deficient too. In a separate article (Bridel, 2020), Sismondi’s twin notion of liberty is explored to demonstrate how, civil liberty, the liberty of the Moderns, is a necessary condition for economic growth which ends up being destroyed by the ‘unlimited freedom of industry’ of the English chrematistic school. After discussing wealth and liberty, happiness is the last element of Sismondi’s trilogy to be examined here and co-ordinated with his economic theory. Using challenging remarks recently offered by Dos Santos Ferreira, Ege and Igersheim (2025), the present essay is an attempt to put the author’s various articles within the perspective of Sismondi’s (expected) sharp critique of utilitarianism (and its consequential notion of happiness). The first part of the article examines systematically his approach and critique of utilitarianism -in connection with Dumont the translator and interpreter of Bentham’s work as well as with Constant’s early aversion for the ‘spirit of the [utilitarian] system’. Clearly, for Sismondi, utilitarianism cannot be a normative value and even less a moral principle: justice must take precedence and is in direct opposition to utilitarianism. For Sismondi, distributional justice is solved prior and outside an (inefficient) price mechanism. Hence, he is suspicious of Bentham’s consequentialism according to which the consequences of any action are the only standard of right and wrong. Similarly, Sismondi seems to anticipate the Rawlsian issue that "utilitarianism does not take seriously the distinction between persons" (including the old problem of aggregation). Building on this critique of utilitarianism, the second part examines Sismondi’s concept of happiness (as a process and not a state) and how it relates to the two prerequisites of liberty and wealth. Direct connections are thus made with results reached in Bridel 2020 and 2021. Freedom and wealth are conditions of possibility for accessing happiness. Sismondi focuses his attention on real (and not merely formal) freedom - and to be real it must necessarily integrate political and economic dimensions. Happiness is clearly placed above liberty and wealth and governments must play a crucial part in both fields to promote “the greatest happiness for the greatest number” via what Sismondi calls political liberty. The third and last part offers some general remarks on the connections between Sismondi’s trilogy and his economic theory to demonstrate once again that the latter is a subset of his moral philosophy.

Area:

Keywords: Sismondi - utilitarianism - moral philosophy and economic theory

Please Login in order to download this file