Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Structuring Knowledge: Economics’ Reception of Thomas Kuhn

Chung Connor, MIT

Over the course of his career, the historian and philosopher Thomas Kuhn wrote almost nothing about economic thought. Yet ever since the publication of his 1962 magnum opus The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, economists have been among the most enthusiastic users of Kuhnian ideas and rhetoric. This paper aims to reconstruct this ubiquitous yet under-studied reception, and ask what it reveals about the broader path of the discipline in the 20th and 21st centuries. Drawing on published writings, archival correspondence, practitioner discourse, and more, I argue that economists’ engagement with Structure has been anything but incidental: that from early on, the work has played a central role in how economists have narrated their field’s past, conceptualized its present, and imagined its future. In doing so, I explore how they have repeatedly made and remade their own Kuhnianisms to suit shifting disciplinary needs. The discipline’s readings have been heterogeneous, idiosyncratic, and original from the start, at times strikingly opposed to dominant interpretations of the day. Yet within them lies a set of stories that have profoundly shaped the way the field talks and thinks. Tracing the course of this reception, I argue, can speak to how economists seek to understand themselves — and to how they have navigated a changing profession and a changing world.

Area:

Keywords: Economics and Science, Economic Rhetoric, Paradigms

Please Login in order to download this file