Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

[Histories of Economic Associations] The Cowles Commission and the Econometric Society, 1931-1960

Dimand Robert, Brock University

The Econometric Society and the Cowles Commission for Research in Economics were closely interlinked in their first three decades of advancing formal mathematical and statistical methods in economics, a relationship that began within a year of the founding of the ES on the last day of 1930. Alfred (Bob) Cowles 3rd, a newspaper heir and investment counsellor, was treasurer of the Econometric Society from 1932 to 1958, the society's secretary from 1937 to 1953 (succeeding Charles F. Roos, research director of the Cowles Commission 1932-37), and business manager of Econometrica as well as president of the Cowles Commission from its founding in Colorado in 1932 until it moved from Chicago in 1955 to become the Cowles Foundation at Yale University. The two organizations shared offices and administrators (successive administrators of the Cowles Commission doubled as managing editors of Econometrica)and each depended on an annual donation from Alfred Cowles. Successive research directors of the Commission and Foundation (Jacob Marschak 1943-48, Tjalling Koopmans 1948-55, James Tobin 1955-61) were presidents of the ES early in their Cowles directorships. This paper explores the relationship between the Econometric Society and the Cowles Commission from the first interaction until the retirement from active participation in the society of Alfred Cowles and of Ragnar Frisch, ES cofounder and editor of Econometrica from its foundation in 1933 until 1960. Frisch and ES founding president Irving Fisher were crucial in persuading sceptics in the Society's council to take seriously Alfred Cowles's offer of funding for conferences, a journal and research organization, and served on the Cowles Commission's advisory council appointed by the ES (replaced after the 1939 move to Chicago by an advisory committee appointed by the University of Chicago). Cowles and Frisch were the two continuing figures guiding the ES to the end of the 1950s as other members of the Society's executive cae and went. Through that period, during which Cowles Commission monographs, Cowles and ES conferences, and Econometrica were the forums for many advances in economic theory and econometrics later honored with Nobel Memorial Prizes, the two organizations were so closely associated that the history of one cannot be understood with out including the history of the other.

Area:

Keywords: Cowles Commission, Econometric Society, history of quantitative methods in economics