Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Malcolm Rutherford and the British Connection of American Institutionalism

Dimand Robert, Brock University

As part of his magisterial scholarship on the history of American institutional economics, Malcolm Rutherford explored on several occasions the British connections of American institutionalism. This paper reexamines these connections in light of Rutherford's studies of "J. A. Hobson and American Institutionalism: Underconsumption and Technical Changes" (in a 1995 edited volume on Hobson), "American Institutionalism and its British Connections" (EJHET 2007), and "The Institutionalism Reaction to Keynesian Economics" (with Tyler DesRoches, JHET 2008). These connections include the influence of the English historical school as represented by W. J. (later Sir William) Ashley as professor of economic history at Harvard from 1892, the influence of Hobson's underconsumption theory in the US and of American institutionalism on Hobson (as seen in Hobson's 1936 book about Veblen), the close attention that Keynes paid to the work of John R. Commons in the 1920s, and the responses of American institutionalists to Keynes and Keynesianism.

Area:

Keywords: Malcolm Rutherford, American institutional economics, English historical school of economics, John R. Commons, John A. Hobson, John Maynard Keynes