Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Pareto, between non-normativity and Welfare Economics

Marquet-Ellis Lucas, Université de Lausanne

Despite the central importance of concepts elaborated by Vilfredo Pareto (1848–1923) in the welfare economics literature (ordinalism and Pareto-efficiency to name the most prominent ones), the epistemological and theoretical status of his work on utility and welfare has not been studied in detail. The recent discussions on the relations between preferences, choices and welfare following the challenges raised by behavioral economics have nonetheless demonstrated the necessity of clarifying the propositions of both positive and normative economics. Studying the evolution of the welfare economics propositions in Pareto’s writings demonstrates how the theories and propositions he defended about welfare crucially depended on his opinion about the possibility of normative statements in economics and on the epistemology underlying his theoretical work. While it seems that he began to study economics for normative purposes, i.e., to defend free-trade and liberalism, he first expressed little concern for normativity and seemed willing to conciliate economic policy with scientific economics, Pareto evolved to a skeptical position about the possibility of normative scientific economics according to which the ideals and goals of a society cannot be the object of rational discussion and study, unless they are treated as sentiments and thus as objects of sociological analysis. This slow shift, combined with other epistemological evolutions, for instance concerning the definition of utility and the foundations of economics, affected his treatment of welfare economics. For instance, Pareto took care to reject any normative interpretation of his concept of the maximum ophelimity for a community (the “Pareto optimum”), which means that he did not present it as a desirable equilibrium position. Nevertheless, this does not mean that Pareto had a neutral welfare theory. I intend to describe the theoretical and ontological presuppositions underlying his economic and sociological writings addressing the questions of individual and social well-being with a discussion of his concepts of ophelimity, individual and social utility. This paper eventually tackles the issue of the use of Pareto’s writings for explicit normative purposes associated with the New Welfare Economics. Indeed, as Pareto only intended to provide normative scientific economics in the beginning of his scientific evolution, it seems that he had different epistemological views and motivations than those of Hicks, Kaldor, Samuelson Bergson, when he wrote his Manual of Political Economy and his Treatise of General Sociology.

Area:

Keywords: Welfare Economics, Pareto, Values

Please Login in order to download this file